ISFL Returner of the Year

Tugg Speedman was named the ISFL Returner of the Year 3 times.

The International Simulation Football League Returner of the Year Award is an award given by the ISFL Head Office & GM committee to the American football player who is considered the best overall kick and punt returner in the last completed season of the International Simulation Football League (NSFL). Since the 2024 (S9) season, the ISFL has held the annual ISFL Awards Ceremony to recognize the winner of the Returner of the Year award and all other awards.

Award winners

The award is voted upon by a panel of 15 dedicated head office members and general managers at the end of the post season, though the results are not announced to the public until the following preseason.

Season	Player	Team	Position
2024 (S9)	Dermot Lavelle	Yellowknife Wraiths	Cornerback
2025 (S10)	Dermot Lavelle (2)	Yellowknife Wraiths	Cornerback
2026 (S11)	Jaylon Broxton	Orange County Otters	Safety
2027 (S12)	Howard Miller	Colorado Yeti	Wide receiver
2028 (S13)	Howard Miller (2)	Colorado Yeti	Wide receiver
2029 (S14)	Vladimir Fyodorovich	New Orleans Second Line	Wide receiver
2030 (S15)	Danny Grithead	Orange County Otters	Safety
2031 (S16)	Lennox Garnett	Philadelphia Liberty	Safety
2032 (S17)	Vinny Valentine	Arizona Outlaws	Wide receiver
2034 (S19)	Forrest Gump	New Orleans Second Line	Running back
2035 (S20)	Forrest Gump (2)	New Orleans Second Line	Running back
2036 (S21)	Walt Green	Baltimore Hawks	Safety
2037 (S22)	Walt Green (2)	Baltimore Hawks	Safety
2038 (S23)	Louisiana Purchase	Colorado Yeti	Cornerback
2039 (S24)	Dermot Lavelle Jr.	Austin Copperheads	Cornerback
2040 (S25)	Ke'oke'o Kane-Maika'i	Honolulu Hahalua	Running back
2041 (S26)	Flash Panda	Philadelphia Liberty	Wide receiver
2042 (S27)	Jackson Kingston	New York Silverbacks	Wide receiver
2043 (S28)	Flash Panda (2)	Philadelphia Liberty	Wide receiver
2044 (S29)	Chizuru Ichinose	Sarasota Sailfish	Running back
2045 (S30)	Andrew Witten	New Orleans Second Line	Cornerback
2046 (S31)	Kai Sakura	Yellowknife Wraiths	Wide receiver
2047 (S32)	Tugg Speedman	New York Silverbacks	Wide receiver
2048 (S33)	Cobra Kai	Honolulu Hahalua	Running back
2049 (S34)	Tugg Speedman (2)	New York Silverbacks	Wide receiver
2050 (S35)	Tugg Speedman (3)	New York Silverbacks	Wide receiver