[DEV] ISFL Forums
*Carmel Gibson has spent too much TPE - Printable Version

+- [DEV] ISFL Forums (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums)
+-- Forum: Community (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Forum: Media (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=37)
+---- Forum: Graded Articles (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=38)
+---- Thread: *Carmel Gibson has spent too much TPE (/showthread.php?tid=3466)

Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14


*Carmel Gibson has spent too much TPE - Oles - 08-18-2017

(08-18-2017, 01:23 PM)7hawk77 Wrote:Yeah but the MLB is also imbalanced and terribly run. There are no salary caps so it's already a shitty uneven playing field. The luxury tax isn't effective.

If you are looking for fair and balanced play leading to healthy competition, baseball shouldn't be your poster child. When some roided out crazy dude is hitting more home runs, that sells more jerseys and tickets. It's in their best interest to not punish this shit. This is a bad analogy.

It's not like there's a whole era of players who used substances and are now basically banned because of how much the game was tainted.


*Carmel Gibson has spent too much TPE - Bafetimbi Gomis - 08-18-2017

SMFH niggas like him can get away with cheating for weeks at a time but if I shitpost just once I get ridiculed for the rest of my life. fucking hell


*Carmel Gibson has spent too much TPE - ErMurazor - 08-18-2017

(08-18-2017, 11:49 AM)Bafetimbi Gomis Wrote:SMFH niggas like him can get away with cheating for weeks at a time but if I shitpost just once I get ridiculed for the rest of my life. fucking hell

Can we ban him for this and award Legion an extra loss. I think this taints their wins against the Hawks.

:rofl: :rofl: :rofl: :rofl:


*Carmel Gibson has spent too much TPE - Valtookan - 08-18-2017

Quote:That's pretty extreme (although it would be 110 TPE) although it makes perfect sense. The problem is, me plus 110 TPE is 340 and Maddox plus 110 TPE is 430. Both of those are higher than our #1 WR, so what's to stop us from lining up at WR?

Unless this is what you had in mind.


We are even further along in the season now, so if the TEs have been continuing to rack up TPE it wouldn't even be as effective as the boost Gibson had.


*Carmel Gibson has spent too much TPE - Bafetimbi Gomis - 08-18-2017

(08-18-2017, 11:14 AM)ErMurazor Wrote:Can we ban him for this and award Legion an extra loss. I think this taints their wins against the Hawks.

:rofl:  :rofl:  :rofl:  :rofl:

Someone got banned for saying nigga on SHL awhile back. Yet people can circumvent cap and/or TPE and only get a suspension at most


*Carmel Gibson has spent too much TPE - Valtookan - 08-18-2017

(08-18-2017, 12:49 PM)Roshambo Wrote:I think Berc said this already, but again, if a player is suspended for failing a piss test for PEDs, the team isn't stripped of wins.  The other 31 teams don't get a free pass to 'roid up one of their players for a few weeks.

Step 1) Player is suspended.
Step 2) Carry on.


Suspended? I think the player should be retired. I understand that this isn't the the Hawks Gms fault ( @HENDRIX @Noppadet) as they shouldn't be expected to hound their players on TPE input. This isn't @Noble or @Bwestfield, at least that is what I've been repeated told so they shouldn't be punished. Still, it is ridiculous and inexcusable for this to happen. This league is built on trust! I remember reading the Rookie Guide and the Reddit recruitment post. @Ballerstorm stated in one or the other (or both) that the league is "User-powered". We should be able to trust our Users to READ THE INSTRUCTIONS and FOLLOW THEM. If that can't be done then you cannot be allowed to play.

I really think strong action should be encouraged here; I understand we don't want to become a scary totalitarian forum page but I really think that we have to move on from this quickly.

I believe Carmel Gibson should be forcible retired by NSFL officials. It should be a vote on forced retirement with the option of an appeal for the user involved. Carmel Gibson is not even active (as I have been told) so this should seriously be considered. The user, if he wishes, should be allowed to join the league once again; but he MUST create a new player. I really think we just need to wash our hands away from Carmel Gibson, the player; not necessarily the user (OF COURSE the user should be given a stern warning, and be watched over very carefully).


*Carmel Gibson has spent too much TPE - 124715 - 08-18-2017

(08-18-2017, 01:50 PM)ErMurazor Wrote:They're going to lose their starting tight end. When a player gets caught using PEDs in the NFL they don't restart the season.

I know, and I'm not suggesting we restart the season. The Hawks used an illegal weapon for 11 games. There will be no consequences after that. That's all I'm saying. The team got an unfair advantage, and nothing will happen to them. They even have another TE waiting in the wings.


*Carmel Gibson has spent too much TPE - 124715 - 08-18-2017

(08-18-2017, 03:50 PM)Valtookan Wrote:Suspended? I think the player should be retired. I understand that this isn't the the Hawks Gms fault ( @HENDRIX @Noppadet) as they shouldn't be expected to hound their players on TPE input. This isn't @Noble or @Bwestfield, at least that is what I've been repeated told so they shouldn't be punished. Still, it is ridiculous and inexcusable for this to happen. This league is built on trust! I remember reading the Rookie Guide and the Reddit recruitment post. @Ballerstorm stated in one or the other (or both) that the league is "User-powered". We should be able to trust our Users to READ THE INSTRUCTIONS and FOLLOW THEM. If that can't be done then you cannot be allowed to play.

I really think strong action should be encouraged here; I understand we don't want to become a scary totalitarian forum page but I really think that we have to move on from this quickly.

I believe Carmel Gibson should be forcible retired by NSFL officials. It should be a vote on forced retirement with the option of an appeal for the user involved. Carmel Gibson is not even active (as I have been told) so this should seriously be considered. The user, if he wishes, should be allowed to join the league once again; but he MUST create a new player. I really think we just need to wash our hands away from Carmel Gibson, the player; not necessarily the user (OF COURSE the user should be given a stern warning, and be watched over very carefully).

This is the easy solution! Take him out of the league! The Hawks just basically had an unfair advantage for 11 games and no punishment is being inflicted!Gibson is going to be suspended, but the Hawks had an unfair advantage for these games.

I'm going to keep pushing for this until Gibson is out of the league and we've gotten something for it. The 110 TPE TE bonus is a good idea (and like @ErMurazor pointed out, not too impactful) so that should happen imo.


*Carmel Gibson has spent too much TPE - Bzerkap - 08-18-2017

(08-18-2017, 03:11 PM)124715 Wrote:This is the easy solution! Take him out of the league! The Hawks just basically had an unfair advantage for 11 games and no punishment is being inflicted!Gibson is going to be suspended, but the Hawks had an unfair advantage for these games.

I'm going to keep pushing for this until Gibson is out of the league and we've gotten something for it. The 110 TPE TE bonus is a good idea (and like @ErMurazor pointed out, not too impactful) so that should happen imo.
Gibson has been released so it doesn't matter


*Carmel Gibson has spent too much TPE - 124715 - 08-18-2017

(08-18-2017, 05:12 PM)Bzerkap Wrote:Gibson has been released so it doesn't matter

I still feel that the Hawks had an unfair advantage which is not being repaid.