![[DEV] ISFL Forums](http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/images/emerald/logo.png "[DEV] ISFL Forums"){kind=logo}
+- [DEV] ISFL Forums (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums)
+-- Forum: Community (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Forum: Media (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=37)
+---- Forum: Graded Articles (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=38)
+---- Thread: *S1 Redraft - 137-100 (/showthread.php?tid=11707)
*S1 Redraft - 137-100 - majesiu - 01-24-2019
S1 Redraft - 137-100 Part 1: Literally irrelevant
S1 Redraft - 99-70 Part 2: The gone before S5 part
S1 Redraft - 69-40 Part 3: First Regression Fighers
S1 Redraft - 39-15 Part 4: It's getting better!
S1 Redraft - 14-1 Part 5: Crème de la crème
Okay, so with upcoming big and stressful event soonish in work I decided to put my procrastination and good tactic known as not thinking of it and being busy with something else and start the seasonal column of redrafts. I long debated whether to focus just on my draft (season 7) as it approaches its peak or whether to start with Season 6 class that just regressed, but can you really grade and do a redraft properly without knowing the class altogether? So with that in mind, we just had last few players (two to be exact) that were drafted in S1 finishing their career just now in S12, in the final game of the season.
We know about who this article will be about, but how I decided to grade players? There will be 4 factors - 3 majors and 1 minor. Due to the sheer amount of players in that draft (137), please forgive me judgment calls in category number 3 & 4, especially since I'm only around since Season 6 and don't have much knowledge about first 5 seasons. The categories:
- Peak TPE/100 - Top mark was 12,22
- Career longevity - 0-12 score depending on seasons spend in the league
- Career quality - 0-13 the first of judgment calls, basically non-factor is going to be 1 (0 if never suited), 2 was a bit better than replacement level, 7 made some pro-bowl and 13 is HoF caliber player. I tried to be lenient in this category, but once again - I'm not writing a dissertation about particular players, just trying to give a nice window back into S1 draft to have revived some memories, find biggest steals, busts and have something to write about. I put also a lower emphasis on the first few seasons since the low TPE levels surmount to really random results.
- Activity Grade - 0 to 5 score, where 0 equals lack update page, 3 was somewhat active and 5 was always active throughout the career
I'll try to write a few words about more interesting players, but more often than not I'll just be using the template I prepared for the occasion. One more note is that searching through these old days wasn't easy and I might have missed some seasons if players position switched for example, for such mistakes sincere apologies and feel free to correct me!
Without further ado let's start with a group of players tied for the last place, and frankly, that likely shouldn't even be drafted, as they never updated or seen the field of action in the NSFL.
Player name: Atahualpa Romero - username: @[Atahualpa]
College: University of Michigan
Position: RB
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S0 - Longevity score: 0
Career Quality Score: 0
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 0,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 23, Pick: 135Redraft Position: 132 - Change: +3
Player name: Logan Ryder - username: @[papap0st]
College: Wisconsin
Position: QB
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S0 - Longevity score: 0
Career Quality Score: 0
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 0,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 20, Pick: 119Redraft Position: 132 - Change: -13
Player name: Granit Lewis - username: @[OwenJH]
College: University of Michigan
Position: WR
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S0 - Longevity score: 0
Career Quality Score: 0
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 0,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 20, Pick: 118Redraft Position: 132 - Change: -14
Player name: Ezekiel Bishop - username: @[WiSeIVIaN]
College: Northern Illinois University
Position: CB
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S0 - Longevity score: 0
Career Quality Score: 0
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 0,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 20, Pick: 116Redraft Position: 132 - Change: -16
Player name: Gilfred Harrison - username: @[GilfredTheGreat]
College: Didn't attend
Position: DT
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S0 - Longevity score: 0
Career Quality Score: 0
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 0,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 18, Pick: 104Redraft Position: 132 - Change: -28
At least teams didn't reach out badly for those players, though this draft was full of steals.
Player name: Jimmy Darkapple - username: @[TheAliensAreCumming]
College: UGA
Position: K
Peak TPE: 84 - TPE Score: 0,84
Last season played in the league: S0 - Longevity score: 0
Career Quality Score: 0
Activity Grade: 1
Overall Score: 1,84
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 14, Pick: 82Redraft Position: 131 - Change: -49
Do you think -49 picks reach was a bad one? You are so wrong, it's only just half of the value of the biggest steal/reach in this draft. It's also a bit puzzling that Yeti had improving kicker that have never played and still drafted him rather high in that draft.
Next 10 picks or more won't be more interesting either, since they stayed in the league, because the meat was needed to fill the roster spots, but their career was mostly meaningless and ended as soon as improved players created.
Player name: Glennie Retro - username: @[Glennie_p]
College: Georgia Southern
Position: LB
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S1 - Longevity score: 1
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 2,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 22, Pick: 132Redraft Position: 123 - Change: +9
Player name: Rickey Mills - username: @[Bronson]
College: Louisiana State University
Position: LB
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S1 - Longevity score: 1
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 2,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 22, Pick: 130Redraft Position: 123 - Change: +7
Player name: Allister Amir - username: @[ChicagoKid4Life]
College: Illinois
Position: DE
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S1 - Longevity score: 1
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 2,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 21, Pick: 125Redraft Position: 123 - Change: +2
Player name: Henri Rivere - username: @[Mosacra]
College: Louisiana State University
Position: CB
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S1 - Longevity score: 1
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 2,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 18, Pick: 107Redraft Position: 123 - Change: -16
Player name: King Arthur - username: @[jeter137]
College: Florida State University
Position: CB
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S1 - Longevity score: 1
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 2,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 17, Pick: 97Redraft Position: 123 - Change: -26
First of badly reached picks by the Otters.
Player name: Brandon Walsh - username: @[Copenhagen]
College: Alabama
Position: K
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S1 - Longevity score: 1
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 2,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 14, Pick: 84Redraft Position: 123 - Change: -39
One more Otters Reach.
Player name: Bill Weller - username: @[Billieck]
College: University of Michigan
Position: TE
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S1 - Longevity score: 1
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 2,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 11, Pick: 63Redraft Position: 123 - Change: -60
Player name: Samuel Watson - username: @[Evolution]
College: Missouri
Position: S
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S1 - Longevity score: 1
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 2,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 10, Pick: 55Redraft Position: 123 - Change: -68
Player name: Matt Smith - username: @[MattSmith518]
College: Penn State University
Position: S
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S2 - Longevity score: 2
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 3,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 22, Pick: 128Redraft Position: 115 - Change: +13
Player name: Zed Richter - username: @[Plastic Bowl]
College: UNC Charlotte
Position: S
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S2 - Longevity score: 2
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 3,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 21, Pick: 124Redraft Position: 115 - Change: +9
Player name: Wizard Stephen - username: @[WizardStephen]
College: University of Michigan
Position: WR
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S2 - Longevity score: 2
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 3,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 19, Pick: 110Redraft Position: 115 - Change: -5
Player name: Everest Teagarden - username: @[xfactorx121]
College: TCU
Position: DE
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S2 - Longevity score: 2
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 3,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 16, Pick: 94Redraft Position: 115 - Change: -21
Player name: Kentilian Laces - username: @[tootboots12]
College: Nevada
Position: K
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S2 - Longevity score: 2
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 3,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 16, Pick: 93Redraft Position: 115 - Change: -22
Player name: Adrienne Nugent - username: @[galatix]
College: Syracuse University
Position: K
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S2 - Longevity score: 2
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 3,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 15, Pick: 90Redraft Position: 115 - Change: -25
Player name: Sunday Showcase - username: @[SundayShowcase]
College: University of Michigan
Position: S
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S1 - Longevity score: 1
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 3,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 9, Pick: 53Redraft Position: 115 - Change: -62
Player name: Khalifa Al Mahrouqi - username: @[formx]
College: Didn't attend
Position: LB
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S1 - Longevity score: 1
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 3,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 4, Pick: 20Redraft Position: 115 - Change: -95
And this category was so full of reaches (average reach in the category of players with an overall score of 3.5 was stunning 26), but formx player takes the crown as the biggest one. Somehow it's not surprising to me. You can also see that a lot of players were of defensive position, suggesting that teams drafted because of need instead of taking best player available - we've come a long way ever since then.
Player name: HFFO Mademe - username: @[Storm]
College: Rutgers University
Position: WR
Peak TPE: 58 - TPE Score: 0,58
Last season played in the league: S1 - Longevity score: 1
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 3,58
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 18, Pick: 105Redraft Position: 113 - Change: -8
Yay finally a player that improved by stunning 8 TPE and stayed in the league for two seasons, really impressive and actually not a worst value for 105th overall pick.
Player name: Eric Hansen - username: @[ESH]
College: Washington State
Position: CB
Peak TPE: 74 - TPE Score: 0,74
Last season played in the league: S1 - Longevity score: 1
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 3,74
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 22, Pick: 129Redraft Position: 112 - Change: +17
Player name: Jack Stats - username: @[Desu]
College: Florida State University
Position: RB
Peak TPE: 75 - TPE Score: 0,75
Last season played in the league: S1 - Longevity score: 1
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 3,75
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 17, Pick: 98Redraft Position: 111 - Change: -13
Player name: Sensabaughdy Leafer - username: @[Leafer]
College: University of Regina Rams
Position: DE
Peak TPE: 96 - TPE Score: 0,96
Last season played in the league: S1 - Longevity score: 1
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 1
Overall Score: 3,96
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 9, Pick: 52Redraft Position: 110 - Change: -58
How the turn tables and flip stools. I'm pretty sure when I get to S6 redraft (in 5 seasons ~9 months?), Leafer is going to be way higher, but he was one of the more monumental busts of the inaugural draft.
Player name: Vicncent Draxel - username: @[701]
College: South Carolina Gamecocks
Position: QB
Peak TPE: 107 - TPE Score: 1,07
Last season played in the league: S1 - Longevity score: 1
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 1
Overall Score: 4,07
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 8, Pick: 43Redraft Position: 109 - Change: -66
The devilish reach that actually led the league in yards and TDs in S1 with astounding 2858 passing yards on 51.4 completion percentage. Something that wasn't done ever since then. Still a career score of 1.
Player name: Trent Bender - username: @[GengarGoat]
College: University Of Florida
Position: QB
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S2 - Longevity score: 2
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 4,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 23, Pick: 134Redraft Position: 106 - Change: +28
Player name: Fernando Bessell - username: @[WillW]
College: Notre Dame
Position: RB
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S3 - Longevity score: 3
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 4,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 22, Pick: 127Redraft Position: 106 - Change: +21
Player name: Cliff Hamilton - username: @[breakingthe4THWALL]
College: Hard Knocks
Position: QB
Peak TPE: 50 - TPE Score: 0,5
Last season played in the league: S3 - Longevity score: 3
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 0
Overall Score: 4,5
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 19, Pick: 109Redraft Position: 106 - Change: +3
Player name: Josh Davidson - username: @[zerxiez]
College: University of Nebraska
Position: TE
Peak TPE: 53 - TPE Score: 0,53
Last season played in the league: S2 - Longevity score: 2
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 1
Overall Score: 4,53
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 23, Pick: 133Redraft Position: 105 - Change: +28
Player name: Wes Washington - username: @[scmsf49]
College: Ohio State University
Position: WR
Peak TPE: 56 - TPE Score: 0,56
Last season played in the league: S2 - Longevity score: 2
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 1
Overall Score: 4,56
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 23, Pick: 138Redraft Position: 104 - Change: +34
Player name: Pablo Sanchez - username: @[baltimoreravens]
College: Georgia Tech
Position: S
Peak TPE: 57 - TPE Score: 0,57
Last season played in the league: S2 - Longevity score: 2
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 1
Overall Score: 4,57
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 22, Pick: 131Redraft Position: 103 - Change: +28
Player name: Lightskin Thor - username: @[DefensiveJesus]
College: Stanford University
Position: DE
Peak TPE: 70 - TPE Score: 0,7
Last season played in the league: S2 - Longevity score: 2
Career Quality Score: 1
Activity Grade: 1
Overall Score: 4,7
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 20, Pick: 120Redraft Position: 102 - Change: +18
Player name: Willam Nasher - username: @[redguy22]
College: University of Texas
Position: DT
Peak TPE: 76 - TPE Score: 0,76
Last season played in the league: S2 - Longevity score: 2
Career Quality Score: 1
Overall Score: 4,76
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 19, Pick: 111Redraft Position: 101 - Change: +10
Player name: Demetrius Wiley - username: @[:.Elite.:]
College: Northern Iowa
Position: RB
Peak TPE: 79 - TPE Score: 0,79
Last season played in the league: S1 - Longevity score: 1
Career Quality Score: 2
Activity Grade: 1
Overall Score: 4,79
Originally Drafted by:
Round: 17, Pick: 100Redraft Position: 100 - Change: 0
The only thing special about this player appears that he'd be drafted in the same position in the redraft as in the original thing.
Okay, just the perfect match - we got through the 37 picks leaving 99 left and I got to the sweet spot of 2500 words for the article. Peace out and see you soon with the next wave. Pls, bonus, a ton of research and not empty word count spewing went into this.
*S1 Redraft - 137-100 - timeconsumer - 01-24-2019
Ezekiel Bishop 1OA IMO
*S1 Redraft - 137-100 - iamslm22 - 01-24-2019
Shocked by how many of these names I recognize, but I think that's cuz a couple were on the Marshals the season I GMed down there
*S1 Redraft - 137-100 - PDXBaller - 01-24-2019
(01-24-2019, 03:46 PM)iamslm22 Wrote:Shocked by how many of these names I recognize, but I think that's cuz a couple were on the Marshals the season I GMed down there
Yeah I remember quite a few as well as the Pythons GM. Remember that sweet Jack Stats trade?!?
*S1 Redraft - 137-100 - manicmav36 - 01-24-2019
This is amazing. Can't wait to see the rest!
*S1 Redraft - 137-100 - iamslm22 - 01-24-2019
(01-24-2019, 06:55 PM)PDXBaller Wrote:Yeah I remember quite a few as well as the Pythons GM. Remember that sweet Jack Stats trade?!?
lmaooo yes I do. That one and the Jameis Christ one
*S1 Redraft - 137-100 - 37thchamber - 01-25-2019
(01-25-2019, 12:32 AM)timeconsumer Wrote:Ezekiel Bishop 1OA IMOThis.
"Easy" the legend. No bishop, no delacour. Never forget. He only retired because he got shot that one time. Not his fault.