[DEV] ISFL Forums
*Grading the Season 15 Draft - Printable Version

+- [DEV] ISFL Forums (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums)
+-- Forum: Community (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Forum: Media (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=37)
+---- Forum: Graded Articles (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=38)
+---- Thread: *Grading the Season 15 Draft (/showthread.php?tid=14100)

Pages: 1 2


*Grading the Season 15 Draft - contacts - 07-01-2019

[div align=\\\"center\\\"]Much has already been said about the massive season 15 crop of rookies, and with a full year in the books, we have a better idea of how the draft played out. I already mentioned some of the gems and busts in my last article, so I wanted to concentrate on the team by team draft classes and see which general managers nailed it and which ones blew it. There was a ton of talent to go around, so most teams got a nice haul - they will be graded relative to other teams picks in this particular draft. Apologies in advance if I missed any draft day trades, I only remembered one so that’s all that made the cut. Feel free to defend your honor if I missed any important nuances moves made that may reflect on your teams score. The scores themselves are calculated by a super complicated algorithm, so I doubt I’ll have the time or computer power to recompute them. I’ve decided to limit this article for the first six rounds for my sanity’s sake, and of course so we can fit the Ryan Leaf Jr. pick in here somehow. Anyway, from worst to first:[/div]

Austin Copperheads:
5. AUS Chase Jensen - S - @dizzyDC - 525 TPE
15. AUS Rod Tidwell - WR - @SDCore - 406 TPE
35. AUS Troy Humhawhatever - S - @Sirearl - 175 TPE
45. AUS Nick Snyder - DT - @eighthroundpick - 124 TPE
55. AUS Michael Rood - TE - @Cross - 112 TPE

The Austin Copperhead came into the league as an expansion team, and fell flat in their first draft. First round pick tight end Chase Jensen was slightly controversial as the first player ever taken by the franchise given the position he played is undervalued, however he has always been an elite TPE earner and is still the most talented player to come out of this draft. He has since switched positions to safety lock down that position for the expansion team. Second round pick Rod Tidwell is also a quality selection, and the active WR gives the Copperheads a building block at the position going forward. Unfortunately, the new franchise out of Austine did not have a third round pick and bungled their next three. S Troy Humiamabigjerk, DT Nick Snider, and TE Micheal Rood all turned out to be inactive busts and really hamper this franchise out of the starting gate. They got two quality players with their first two picks but the rest of the draft looks ugly after year one.

Grade: C-

They landed two studs, but failed to secure a depth a new franchise should is such a deep draft.


San Jose Sabrecats:
10. SJS Ahri Espeeyeeseetee - WR - @steelsound - 391 TPE
20. SJS Cameron Olsen - TE - @Rradum - 486 TPE
30. SJS Dan Wright - TE - @nickyvmlp - 457 TPE
50. SJS JoJo Burr-Kirven - LB - @Rindiee - 136 TPE
60. SJS Tyler Janes - RB - @Newbie - 106 TPE

The San Jose Sabrecats entered the draft with the last slot in each round, thanks to an Ultimus win on the back of a strong running game and a strong defense. They used the first three rounds to give franchise QB Joliet Christ more receiving weapons. In the first round they picked up WR Ahri Espeeyeeseetee, who has no soul and below average TPE for a first rounder. His only saving grace is at least that abomination of a name is phonetic. Curiously enough, they went back to back tight ends in round two and three, drafting TE Cameron Olsen and TE Dan Wright. It was a deep draft for tight ends this year, and both picks were great values at their draft slot - it will be interesting to see how the team will utilize “The Large Lads” on the field. The rest of their picks were misses.

Grade: C

The SabreCats walked away from the draft with three nice offensive weapons, but didn’t have the firepower some of the other teams had. Also, unlike the other two annoying long names in this draft, we are probably gonna by typing Ahri’s for a while. That’s a deduction.


Colorado Yeti:
11. COL Mo Berry - LB - @Frick_Nasty - 476 TPE
22. COL Tony Gabagool - LB - @shipwreckrising - 366 TPE
31. COL Terry Taffy - RB - @KingCollins - 396 TPE
37. COL Quentin Sinclair - S - @MaxGnarland - 333 TPE
43. COL Jay Longshaw - QB - @dropbear - 198 TPE
52. COL Frasier Crane - DE - @TheFlash - 106 TPE

The Colorado Yeti didn’t have a first round pick this year, but were lucky to land LB Mo berry with the first pick of the second round. Unfortunately for a team rebuilding, he was their only high end TPE gainer in a draft chock full of them. They were however able to add a trio of players in the third and fourth round that are on their way to develop into quality starters - LB Tony Gabagool, RB Terry Taffy, and S Quentin Sinclair. Taffy in particular had himself a great rookie season, and looks like a future star which is great value for a fourth round pick.

Grade: B-

Even without a first round pick, The Yeti avoided weak draft by getting great value out of Berry and Taffy.


New Orleans Second Line:
2. NOLA Quenton Bode - LB - @terriblehippo - 407 TPE
3. NOLA Johnny Slothface - LB - @slothfacekilla - 439 TPE
13. NOLA Forrest Gump - RB - @TomHanks - 376 TPE
27. NOLA Deon Taylor - CB - @BrewCrew - 369 TPE
33. NOLA Marquees Acho - LB - @Huskies311 - 257 TPE
38. NOLA Brave Ulysses - OL - @PaytonM34 - 276 TPE
57. NOLA Tobias Chase - CB - @Qux - 99 TPE

New Orleans had both the second and the third picks in the draft, and ended up going defense early and often. They landed a pair of quality linebackers in Bode and Slothface early, locked up RB of the future in Forrest Gump with their single second round pick, and added a solid corner in Deon Taylor in round three. In the fourth round they added a pair of good but not great TPE earners in linebacker Acho and offensive lineman Ulysses, but neither player projects to be difference makers at this point in their careers. In all, the Second Line added four quality starters, including a couple of valuable linebackers, but had a ton of draft capital and didn’t hit any home runs.

Grade: B

The Second line added quantity, but weren’t able to add the quality that other teams in the draft were able to.


Chicago Butchers:
6. CHI Lightsout Lewis - LB - @flyeaglesfly29 - 474 TPE
16. CHI Xerxes Ridley - CB - @plantane - 480 TPE
26. CHI Guy Nikko - LB - @Duress - 422 TPE
36. CHI Jack Rambo - S - @oz3700 - 306 TPE
46. CHI Timmy Hoss - TE - @smaxx77 - 191 TPE
56. CHI Ben Bortboy - RB - @spinarnie - 159 TPE

The second expansion team in this years draft was the Chicago Butchers, and they did substantially better than their Texan counterparts, landing four quality starters to their two. The Butchers stayed true to their draft slot, drafting out of their original slot in the first six rounds of the draft and ended up getting some solid value with their mid round picks. After taking a pair pair of absolute stud defensive players in linebacker Lightsout Lewis and cornerback Xerxes Ridley, the Butchers took linebacker Guy Nikko and safety Jack Rambo in rounds three and four respectively. Both of those players provided excellent value and the quadruplet of defensive picks will go a long way to shaping the future of the Chicago defense. The next two Chicago picks were offensive selections, and they seem to be middling prospects as both TE Timmy Hoss and RB Ben Bortboy have mediocre TPE gains. However, both players can still fill depth roles, so this expansion teams first draft really outshines their Austin competitors.

Grade: B

The Butchers did not butcher this draft class (I’ll never not use this pun), adding no less than 4 defensive building blocks.

Baltimore Hawks:
12. BAL Fatih Terim - S - @Eco - 510 TPE
17. BAL Walt Green - S - @Duilio05 - 500 TPE
23. BAL Dorfus Jimbo - RB - @ScorpXCracker - 269 TPE
47. BAL Ludicolo Bigby - RB - @TheWoZy - 255 TPE
53. BAL Jacob Rowan - OL - @Vedin - 166 TPE

The Baltimore Hawks had star quarterback Childish Gambino announce this would be his final season, and the team went all in for an Ultimus run before they had to retool the crucial position. It worked, as they enter the current off season as reigning champs. It also depleted their draft capital, as they were the only team without a first round pick this year. Luckily for them, they were able to add to studs safeties in the second round, picking up S Faith Terim and S Walt Green. They each paid immediate dividends, playing crucial roles for the championship team. They followed up the two safeties with a pair of running backs in Dorfus Jimbo and Ludicolo Bigby. While both look like can contribute at backups in the NSFL, they don’t look like an heir apparent to aging workhouse Marquise Brown.

Grade: B

The Hawks second round safety pair was coup. Light on high-end talent after that, but the Champions have Ultimus to ease their pain.

Yellowknife Wraiths:
4. YKW Nero Alexander - DE - @shadyshoelace - 491 TPE
14. YKW Morgan Marshall - RB - @EnfysNest - 428 TPE
24. YKW Logan Uchiha - S - @CalvinP - 380 TPE
34. YKW Giannis Croustis - S - @AirCrou - 382 TPE
54. YKW Ryan Leaf Jr. - DT - @ValorX77 - 336 TPE

The Yellowknife Wraiths had all of their original picks save their fifth rounder, and made them all count with quality draft picks throughout. Fourth overall pick DE Nero Alexander has consistently out produced the two defensive players taken before him in TPE and running back Morgan Marshall had a solid rookie season and looks to be a franchise back after year one. Add in a pair of quality safeties, and an ever enigmatic but now consistent TPE earner in Ryan Leaf Jr, the Wraiths had themselves a heck of a draft.

Grade: B+

Yellowknife had solid picks throughout the draft, although only one elite TPE guy. Still, a massive foundation for the future.

Orange County Otters:
8. OCO AJ Lattimer - DT - @TeyvonSchavari - 427 TPE
18. OCO Lanzer Grievous - LB - @[Rising Equinox] - 460 TPE
28. OCO Franklin Armstrong - QB - @moonlight - 445 TPE
42. OCO Alex Dasistwirklichseinnachname - K/P - @BigKicks - 311 TPE
44. OCO Apollo Reed - RB - @NylarthePhoenix - 305 TPE
51. OCO Cale Clay - DT - @Claymore - 90 TPE
58. OCO RKANSAW N/A - RB - @PratJ - 84 TPE

The Orange County Otters, drafting out of the 8th spot, had an excellent draft as their first five picks look like locks to contribute at a high level in the NSFL. They picked up two high-end defensive prospects in DT Lattimore and LB Grevious, before adding a QB of the future in Franklin Armstrong. At the time, this was somewhat of a surprise as their franchise QB Gus Showbiz was a season removed from winning the Ultimus, but the Otters didn’t pass up a chance to draft the QB coming off an Ultimini win that was falling down ala Aaron Rodgers. Much like the Farve/Rodgers situation, Armstrong should be able to step in for an aging Showbiz at a high level right away - This pick could end up providing amazing long term value late in the third round. Without a pick in round four, they followed up the Armstrong pick with two hits in the fifth round - K Alex Dasdamintalltohell, and RB Apollo Reed. Finding two picks that contributed right away as NSFL rookies in the fifth round in impressive.

Grade: A-

The Otters had an amazing draft and probably earned an A, but they drafted an annoying long name, so that hurt their score. It was a the kicker position however, so the total score deduction was minimal.

Philadelphia Liberty:
9. PHI Richard D'Attoria - S - @124715 - 485 TPE
19. PHI Emondov Emoji - CB - @BWIII - 528 TPE
29. PHI Nacho Varga - WR - @Fordhammer - 482 TPE
39. PHI Rock Hardshaft - LB - @Rouchicus - 184 TPE
49. PHI Farley Hank - RB - @Beebob - 273 TPE
59. PHI Momodou Jallow - S - @usarice - 83 TPE

The Philidephia Liberty also stayed true to their draft slot, the ninth pick in each round, and really knocked it out of the park with their first three picks, selecting S Richard D’Attoria, CB Emondov Emoji and WR Nacho Varga. All three have shown top half of round talent through this point in time, so landing throughout the first three rounds quite impressive. They missed on their next pick, but were able to add RB Farley Hank late in round five, who will provide them quality depth in their backfield.

Grade: A

The top three draft picks for the Liberty were home runs, and landed a decent player late as well.


Arizona Outlaws:
1. ARI Brock Landers - WR - @gucci - 494 TPE
7. ARI Ricardo Morris - DT - @Roly - 485 TPE
21. ARI Lucas Knight - CB - @[ven_knight] - 440 TPE
25. ARI Lamont McKinnie - S - @SouljaBoy2007 - 476 TPE
40. CHI AdamS Martavius Mack - S - @Allplanet (in a draft day trade) - 223 TPE
41. ARI Jammerson Irving - TE - @contacts - 437 TPE
48. ARI Allen Josh - LB - @NamelessNate - 158 TPE

The Arizona Outlaws were the worst team in the league, so they had the first pick but also consistently nailed each selection throughout the draft. They manoeuvred around a lot and ended up with a pair of first round picks and a pair of third round picks - they used them efficiently and drafted 4 high TPE starters. Their one misstep was trading a season 16 first round pick for 4th round safety Mack - he stalled at 223 TPE and has not been active. A weak season 16 class dampens the pain of that trade, as does the signing of star safety Bucky Brooks, so the Outlaws have at worst a decent backup and possibly another future starter if the player becomes active again. Fifth round pick Jammerson Irving was a late round gem, and if the Jamacian tight end would stop smoking pot, write some media and buy some equipment he would clock in at over 470 TPE. All said and done, the Outlaws drafted five highly active starters that were also automatically protected from the expansion draft.

Grade: A++

The Outlaws had a nearly flawless draft at a pivotal time, and are primed for a big year following expansion. Also, each prospect had unusually high levels of chillness and coolness which was heavily weighted in the grading algorithms, naturally.




[div align=\\\"left\\\"]I’m really interested in seeing how the season 16 class stacks up to this one after their first year, since the sheer number of season 15 players still active may be more than the active season 16 players total. Especially with the expansion draft, this draft could turn out to be a game changer this season with so much player movement around the league - especially at the quarterback position. I think there will much more disparity in the season predictions this year, parity around the league in general, and perhaps a crazy playoffs with so many teams making it in. [/div]


*Grading the Season 15 Draft - Bigred1580 - 07-01-2019

Think we are a little low, but super solid write up! Keep up the good work man!
YKW YKW YKW YKW YKW


*Grading the Season 15 Draft - AdamS - 07-01-2019

you missed the drafting of olineman edmund beaver dantes, and the martavius mack selection that arizona traded for was the copperheads, not the butchers

not that either of those really effect our scoring, im sure


*Grading the Season 15 Draft - SouljaBoy2007 - 07-01-2019

Bucky Brooks? Who’s that? Great article tho.


*Grading the Season 15 Draft - Jonny2x - 07-02-2019

Great read!

Yellow Knife was wronged a bit here. I think they easily slide into 2nd overall with an A+.

No arguing the craziness that was the Outlaws draft, but YK beats out 3 and 4 in total TPE (under 100 TPE = 0 in my book as they will never add anything to the club) and all 5 picks are very active in the community.


*Grading the Season 15 Draft - Bigred1580 - 07-02-2019

(07-02-2019, 04:33 AM)Jonny2x Wrote:Great read!

Yellow Knife was wronged a bit here.  I think they easily slide into 2nd overall with an A+.

No arguing the craziness that was the Outlaws draft, but YK beats out 3 and 4 in total TPE (under 100 TPE = 0 in my book as they will never add anything to the club) and all 5 picks are very active in the community.

Oh you!


*Grading the Season 15 Draft - Fordhammer - 07-02-2019

I really enjoy content like this. Nice to see Philly getting some love!

Gotta agree with the others, that it seems like the Wraiths could have gotten an A+++ after somehow managing to hit on all 5 picks. Really well done.


*Grading the Season 15 Draft - TomHanks - 07-02-2019

(07-01-2019, 05:32 PM)contacts Wrote:In all, the Second Line added four quality starters, including a couple of valuable linebackers, but had a ton of draft capital and didn’t hit any home runs.

Imagine drafting the DSFL RBotY/MVP and the (tied for) DSFL LBotY/DPotY and getting told you didn’t hit any home runs smdh

But seriously great write up!


*Grading the Season 15 Draft - Huskies311 - 07-02-2019

I was drafted by the Hawks, not New Orleans, and have over 100 more TPE than listed.

Good write-up though. This Hawks class is looking to repeat


*Grading the Season 15 Draft - Roly - 07-02-2019

Love it - awesome write up