[DEV] ISFL Forums
Getting SNUBBED - Printable Version

+- [DEV] ISFL Forums (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums)
+-- Forum: Community (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Forum: Media (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=37)
+---- Forum: Graded Articles (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=38)
+---- Thread: Getting SNUBBED (/showthread.php?tid=1790)



Getting SNUBBED - Blaster - 07-06-2017

"Wait, who is this guy?" Probably what most of you guys are wondering as you click on this article and start skimming through. We recently were able to vote for Pro-Bowlers as a league and you can click HERE to check out the votes throughout the league or even vote yourself if you haven't already.

[Image: 1995-Reggie-White-Brett-Favre-05284619.jpg]

Let's take a look at the league's BEST Defensive Ends right now.

- NSFC

E. Teagarden, J. Spearhead

Those two are an obvious choice (Personally I feel Spearhead performed better than Teagarden but that's just my opinion) as no one else in the NSFC came close to them when we are talking about top Defensive End talent.

- ASFC

Now the ASFC is a little bit tighter than the NSFC when it comes to the defensive end position. The four names that stick out to me are
- Jayce Tuck
- Dental Dam
- Blaster Blade
- Adamle Tomlinson

Three out of Four are from the Arizona Outlaws. Now that is tough, as you have three top defensive ends that are on the same team splitting time with each other but that's a different story for a different time.

At this time, the two winners of the Pro-Bowl vote are Jayce Tuck and Adamle Tomlinson, cutting out Dental Dam and Blaster Blade. Jayce Tuck is an obvious choice as he dominated defenses with the stat line of 47 tackles (Tied for 3rd in the League, 1st in ASFC among DEs) 17 TFL (Tied for 2nd in the league amongst DEs) 1 Forced Fumble, 1 Fumble Recovery, and 16 Sacks (1st amongst all defensive ends). He's clearly the best DE in the league so that is one spot we are taking from the two available spots at DE in the Pro-Bowl for the ASFC side.

ASFC DE - Jayce Tuck, DE - ?

Now the competition for the second spot is between Dental Dam, Blaster Blade, and Adamle Tomlinson. In a blind vote not based on names would look like this.

Player 1 - 47 Tackles 3 TFL 2 FF 1 FR 9 Sacks

Player 2 - 47 Tackles 17 TFL 2 FF 7 Sacks

Player 3 - 42 Tackles 15 TFL 10 Sacks

Now in plain sight you can see that even though Player 1 is tied with Player 2's tackles, he has a measly 3 TFL and that just won't make the cut when you are comparing with the other two who have 12+ more TFL than him and I feel like anyone would cut him out of the discussion. Player 1 is Dental Dam.

Player 2 - 47 Tackles 17 TFL 2 FF 7 Sacks
Player 3 - 42 Tackles 15 TFL 10 Sacks

The difference between the two - Player 2, 5 more tackles, 2 more TFL, 2 more FF. Player 3, 3 more sacks.

Player 3 has been picked more than Player 2 through the voting system. Why? Is it a popularity contest or do people actually value 5 Tackles, 2 TFL, 2 FF < 3 Sacks?

Player 2 is Blaster Blade
Player 3 is Adamle Tomlinson

Now me making this article is not to bash on the other DEs that are competing against me for the spot. I have respect for the other DEs and I have even told Tomlinson at the beginning of the season that I really liked how he played. But really is 3 more sacks more valuable than what Blade has done better than Tomlinson this season? Or are we just pulling names out of nowhere?

I personally think if you're sane, you would not pick 3 Sacks over 5 Tackles, 2 TFL, 2 FF.

Result: Jayce Tuck - Outlaws , Blaster Blade - Outlaws

Blaster Blade is getting snubbed. He's just a Season 2 player who is already performing better than some S1 players. Watch out next season.


Getting SNUBBED - Noble - 07-06-2017

I left you off my list BECAUSE you're a season two player and I wasn't sure you were even eligible which is what I assume is other people's reasoning.


Getting SNUBBED - Blaster - 07-06-2017

(07-06-2017, 06:25 PM)Noble Wrote:I left you off my list BECAUSE you're a season two player and I wasn't sure you were even eligible which is what I assume is other people's reasoning.

I think if I wasn't eligible it would say "no season two players". But I understand what you're saying. But other people's reasoning? Probably because they were too lazy to look at the list of DEs and just picked two that were the "Biggest" names in the conference



Getting SNUBBED - deadendpath27 - 07-06-2017

(07-06-2017, 06:44 PM)Blaster Wrote:I think if I wasn't eligible it would say "no season two players". But I understand what you're saying. But other people's reasoning? Probably because they were too lazy to look at the list of DEs and just picked two that were the "Biggest" names in the conference

The reason why nobody is choosing you or Teagarden is probably because Fulton/Wozy/Saint and Stropko/Tuck/Ernston are generating all the pressure and you guys are just cleaning up with tackles and a few sacks. The guys bringing the pressure and getting more sacks stand out more. You have to consider how much pressure LBs are generating because some teams are in a 3-4 scheme. If you were the #1 guy on your DL and your LBs weren't beasts you'd get my vote 10/10.


Getting SNUBBED - Blaster - 07-06-2017

(07-06-2017, 06:56 PM)deadendpath27 Wrote:The reason why nobody is choosing you or Teagarden is probably because Fulton/Wozy/Saint and Stropko/Tuck/Ernston are generating all the pressure and you guys are just cleaning up with tackles and a few sacks. The guys bringing the pressure and getting more sacks stand out more. You have to consider how much pressure LBs are generating because some teams are in a 3-4 scheme. If you were the #1 guy on your DL you'd get my vote 10/10.

But is a TFL not enough? Sacks definitely have some weight but when you are getting more tackles, tfl, forced fumbles (Huge pressure and huge play for the team) and only behind by 3 sacks? I should at least be picked over the players being picked now. I understand what you're saying but I'm #2 and I'm doing better than some #1 DE on other teams.



Getting SNUBBED - deadendpath27 - 07-06-2017

(07-06-2017, 07:07 PM)Blaster Wrote:But is a TFL not enough? Sacks definitely have some weight but when you are getting more tackles, tfl, forced fumbles (Huge pressure and huge play for the team) and only behind by 3 sacks? I should at least be picked over the players being picked now. I understand what you're saying but I'm #2 and I'm doing better than some #1 DE on other teams.

All things considered, you do have a strong case. However with the strength of your team's defense a lot of your success might come from your teammates generating pressure. Good example, Teagarden is an inactive player and somehow still has pretty solid numbers because of our defense's ability to create pressure.

When it came time to make a decision, I went with Tomlinson over you because he is by far the #1 guy on that great OCO DL and because he generated slightly more pressure. You are a big impact in the run game, which helped you to get a lot of TFLs and FFs. When I look at DEs I'm more inclined to salivate over a guy with more stripes in the passing game, though. You are pretty much without a doubt the next guy I'd pick at DE, since it was really close with you and Tomlinson. If you had another sack or two, you'd have gotten my vote TBH.

DE is a tough position compared to everything else. While you have 5 OL making the pro-bowl, you only have 4 DL and 4 LBs. If it was up to me, I'd make it 3 DEs per conference to balance it, but since the cutoff is 2 DE per conference, Tomlinson edged by you because of the sacks and circumstances.

I do think your player is awesome and deserves to be a pro-bowler. If you're not making it this year, just use it as a chip on your shoulder for next season, man. You weren't even in the S1 draft? and you're probably a top 5 DE in the entire league already. You have a lot to look forward to and I wouldn't let getting snubbed on some slight technicalities get you down.


Getting SNUBBED - Blaster - 07-06-2017

(07-06-2017, 07:22 PM)deadendpath27 Wrote:All things considered, you do have a strong case. However with the strength of your team's defense a lot of your success might come from your teammates generating pressure. Good example, Teagarden is an inactive player and somehow still has pretty solid numbers because of our defense's ability to create pressure. 

When it came time to make a decision, I went with Tomlinson over you because he is by far the #1 guy on that great OCO DL and because he generated slightly more pressure. You are a big impact in the run game, which helped you to get a lot of TFLs and FFs. When I look at DEs I'm more inclined to salivate over a guy with more stripes in the passing game, though. You are pretty much without a doubt the next guy I'd pick at DE, since it was really close with you and Tomlinson. If you had another sack or two, you'd have gotten my vote TBH.

DE is a tough position compared to everything else. While you have 5 OL making the pro-bowl, you only have 4 DL and 4 LBs. If it was up to me, I'd make it 3 DEs per conference to balance it, but since the cutoff is 2 DE per conference, Tomlinson edged by you because of the sacks and circumstances.

I do think your player is awesome and deserves to be a pro-bowler. If you're not making it this year, just use it as a chip on your shoulder for next season, man. You weren't even in the S1 draft? and you're probably a top 5 DE in the entire league already. You have a lot to look forward to and I wouldn't let getting snubbed on some slight technicalities get you down.

I understand completely what you are saying. Thank you for your input to my article. I also felt 3 DE is a better number but I see why the cutoff is at 2. Your perspective is definitely correct in a different way, just a little different from mine. But thank you, I will try to make it next season if I don't make it this season.




Getting SNUBBED - deadendpath27 - 07-06-2017

(07-06-2017, 08:47 PM)Blaster Wrote:I understand completely what you are saying. Thank you for your input to my article. I also felt 3 DE is a better number but I see why the cutoff is at 2. Your perspective is definitely correct in a different way, just a little different from mine. But thank you, I will try to make it next season if I don't make it this season.

You got it home slice :lift: best of luck!


Getting SNUBBED - Jiggly_333 - 07-12-2017

Graded

Word Count: 643
Bonus Tier: $400k

Total Payout: $1.043M