[DEV] ISFL Forums
*Crisco Absolutely Robbed by Awards Committee - Printable Version

+- [DEV] ISFL Forums (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums)
+-- Forum: Community (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Forum: Media (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=37)
+---- Forum: Graded Articles (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=38)
+---- Thread: *Crisco Absolutely Robbed by Awards Committee (/showthread.php?tid=19474)

*Crisco Absolutely Robbed by Awards Committee - Ryan0413 - 02-26-2020

Hey folks, Alfredo Crisco here, current Punter of the Year and the guy who should have been Kicker of the Year. I know I know, special teams, who gives a shit? Well, I do dammit, I wanted to win both and I should have won both. It's like the awards committee just votes based off of name recognition instead of looking at stats or something.

So ForThe Brand won Kicker of the Year, let's compare his stats to mine. I'll make the font big, the bolded and italicized number represents the higher number for those who can't read statistics well:

  • XPA: 35 (Brand) ------ 36 (Crisco)
  • XPM: 33 (Brand) ------ 35 (Crisco)
  • XP%: 94.3% (Brand) ------ 97.2% (Crisco)
  • FGM: 21 (Brand) ------ 31 (Crisco)
  • FG%: 84% (Brand) ------ 91.2% (Crisco)
  • Longest Kick: 48 yards (Brand) ------ 65 yards (Crisco)


So uh, yeah. Not really sure why I got absolutely robbed for Kicker of the Year. Maybe the voters just vote on whoever they recognize the most? Anyway, as you can see by my stats, I was a better kicker than Brand in quite literally every single category. The worst part? I didn't even finish second in voting, Herbert Prohaska did, so let's take a look at how we compare with each other:

  • XPA: 37 (Prohaska) ------ 36 (Crisco)
  • XPM: 36 (Prohaska) ------ 35 (Crisco)
  • XP%: 97.3% (Prohaska) ------ 97.2% (Crisco)
  • FGA: 20 (Prohaska) ------ 34 (Crisco)
  • FGM: 19 (Prohaska) ------ 31 (Crisco)
  • FG%: 95% (Prohaska) ------ 91.2% (Crisco)
  • Longest Kick: 52 yards (Brand) ------ 65 yards (Crisco)


Now that's a much closer battle, but one I still think I am better in. For extra points, he just had one more attempt which gave him a better XP%, so let's just call that basically a tie. Which, as a rookie, is pretty great to be tied in a category with a maxed out kicker. Then we go to the field goals, which is where I take the advantage. Yeah he had a better FG%, but holy shit, 31 field goals made to 19. Oh and a record breaking longest kick at 65 yards.

So in short, I, Alfredo "Thighmaster" Crisco, was completely robbed by the awards voters for Kicker of the Year. Read the stats people. Also, maybe this proves that the power kicker archetype is a very viable option, perhaps, dare I say, better than accuracy? Sounds like another thought for another day.

*Crisco Absolutely Robbed by Awards Committee - retrospace111 - 02-26-2020

I agree, the voting was a bit biased of course not every GM has the best agenda in mind

*Crisco Absolutely Robbed by Awards Committee - Ryan0413 - 02-26-2020

(02-26-2020, 11:51 PM)retrospace111 Wrote:I agree, the voting was a bit biased of course not every GM has the best agenda in mind
I'd say extremely biased and yeah, I know it's special teams so no one really cares but it matters to us special teams guys

*Crisco Absolutely Robbed by Awards Committee - infinitempg - 02-26-2020

Hey, so actually I'm going to make an announcement about this, but there was a mistake that I made.

The Punter and Kicker of the Year awards are switched. Forthe Brand is actually the Punter of the Year, and Alfredo Crisco is the Kicker of the Year.

Interestingly enough, Crisco got the most first place votes for PotY as well (5 to 4 for Prohaska and 3 for Brand). But it gets better - though I will have to do more digging before I can officially talk about it.

*Crisco Absolutely Robbed by Awards Committee - Ryan0413 - 02-26-2020

(02-27-2020, 12:06 AM)infinitempg Wrote:Hey, so actually I'm going to make an announcement about this, but there was a mistake that I made.

The Punter and Kicker of the Year awards are switched. Forthe Brand is actually the Punter of the Year, and Alfredo Crisco is the Kicker of the Year.

Interestingly enough, Crisco got the most first place votes for PotY as well (5 to 4 for Prohaska and 3 for Brand). But it gets better - though I will have to do more digging before I can officially talk about it.
[Image: pnzJTq3.gif]

Am I gonna have to make a, "Crisco Absolutely Robbed by Awards Committee Pt. 2"?

*Crisco Absolutely Robbed by Awards Committee - infinitempg - 02-26-2020

(02-26-2020, 11:09 PM)Ryan0413 Wrote:[Image: pnzJTq3.gif]

Am I gonna have to make a, "Crisco Absolutely Robbed by Awards Committee Pt. 2"?

I don't think so. I'm 90% sure that it's not foul play and a weird error from the Google Form. We will see.

*Crisco Absolutely Robbed by Awards Committee - Ryan0413 - 02-26-2020

(02-27-2020, 12:14 AM)infinitempg Wrote:I don't think so. I'm 90% sure that it's not foul play and a weird error from the Google Form. We will see.
[Image: tenor.gif?itemid=5937435]
So, there's still a chance I could win Punter of the Year too? If there's a miscount of some order

*Crisco Absolutely Robbed by Awards Committee - infinitempg - 02-26-2020

Please see this announcement. http://nsfl.jcink.net/index.php?act=ST&f=205&t=19670

*Crisco Absolutely Robbed by Awards Committee - retrospace111 - 02-27-2020

(02-27-2020, 12:49 AM)infinitempg Wrote:Please see this announcement. http://nsfl.jcink.net/index.php?act=ST&f=205&t=19670
YESSIR