Sigs 7.25.20 - Printable Version +- [DEV] ISFL Forums (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums) +-- Forum: Community (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=5) +--- Forum: Graphics (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=39) +---- Forum: Graded Weekly Submissions (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=41) +---- Thread: Sigs 7.25.20 (/showthread.php?tid=24231)

Sigs 7.25.20 - SchwarzNarr - 07-25-2020 Sig 1 Sig 2 Sig 3 Sig 4 Sig 5 Sig 6 Sig 7 Sig 8 Sig 9 Sig 10 Sig 11 Sig 12 Sig 13 Memey sig cos murder moose RE: Sigs 7.25.20 - Thor - 08-08-2020 1: 4/7 $1,500,000 2: 3/7 $1,000,000 3: 5/7 $2,000,000 4: 1/7 $100,000 5: 5/7 $2,000,000 6: 3/7 $1,000,000 7: 3/7 $1,000,000 8: 1/7 $100,000 9: 2/7 $500,000 10: 2/7 $500,000 11: 3/7 $1,000,000 12: 3/7 $1,000,000 13: 3/7 $1,000,000 14: 1/7 $100,000 Total: $12,800,000 I'm not going to lie to you, it's pretty hard to grade the Moose signatures due to the fact there's no player and no jersey swaps - the effects are good, some of the signature images are simple and while I like their aesthetic and blending there's not a ton to them for me to work with on grading either. It's also difficult for me to give you feedback on them, especially with so many images so I'll make a few quick points but you know where to find me if you aren't sure why I gave any of the grades that you've received, always happy to talk to you more about them! Sig 1: The blending is good and I like your use of the firework overlays, though the render came out a little bit washed out at the end of it - try to make that more of the focus of your image instead of the text! Sig 3: I like this one a lot as a concept and the jersey swaps are good - you've definitely paid attention to the detail on them, but again the renders are a little bit washed out and faded and the background could use a bit of love to eliminate some of the dead space. Try to match the swap colours if you can as well to keep their jerseys the same colour. Sig 5: As above render is a little washed out but the swap came together well though the colours are a little off the typical otter orange. Shadowing added is a great touch, but to nitpick the lighting from a field like that would create multiple crossedover shadows. Sig 6: I like a lot for the tearing effect Sigs 4, 8 and 14 were graded as memes. If you have questions about your grade you can message myself or @caltroit_red_flames, or submit your submission for arbitration here: http://nsfl.jcink.net/index.php?showtopic=21685 RE: Sigs 7.25.20 - caltroit_red_flames - 08-11-2020 1.) Approved 2.) Approved 3.) Approved with Changes - 4/7 $1,500,000 4.) Approved with Changes - 2/7 $500,000 5.) Approved with Changes - 4/7 $1,500,000 6.) Approved 7.) Approved 8.) Approved 9.) Approved 10.) Approved 11.) Approved 12.) Approved 13.) Approved with Changes - 4/7 $1,500,000 14.) Approved Total: $12,700,000