DDSPF is dumb, here's how I think the tiebreakers went down

DDSPF is dumb, here's how I think the tiebreakers went down - Printable Version

+- [DEV] ISFL Forums (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums)
+-- Forum: Community (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Forum: Discussion (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=33)
+--- Thread: DDSPF is dumb, here's how I think the tiebreakers went down (/showthread.php?tid=25592)

DDSPF is dumb, here's how I think the tiebreakers went down - infinitempg - 09-11-2020

SO you've probably seen now that despite being 3rd in the standings, Arizona is 4th in the playoff seeding and therefore not actually a playoff team.

This is dumb, but whatever. How did this happen? I think I may have figured it out.

Code:
4 WAY TIE BREAKER

 Head to Head

 SJS: 4-2 (2 wins over NOLA)

 OCO: 3-3 

 NO:  2-4 (2 losses to SJS)

 ARI: 3-3

SJS ADVANCE

--

3 WAY TIE BREAKER

 Head to Head

 OCO: 2-2

 NO:  2-2

 ARI: 2-2

 CONF RECORD

 OCO: 5-5

 NO:  5-5

 ARI: 4-6

 POINTS FOR

 OCO: 375

 NO:  336

 ARI: 348

OCO ADVANCE

--

2 WAY TIE BREAKER

 Head to Head

 NO:  1-1

 ARI: 1-1

 CONF RECORD

 NO:  5-5

 ARI: 4-6

NOLA ADVANCE

So, the regular standings page probably only tiebreaks by the first head to head and calls it a day, splitting any further ties by H2H/PF if necessary but just going with the overall order it started with. The playoff system seems to be only looking for the top team in each, and then starting over again.

Hope that makes sense. JK it doesn't but maybe this will clear things up.

RE: DDSPF is dumb, here's how I think the tiebreakers went down - NicholasTheGreat - 09-12-2020

Can you use code to make me happy again?

RE: DDSPF is dumb, here's how I think the tiebreakers went down - JPach - 09-12-2020

infinite, for playoff seeding i think it takes ARI and NOLA H2H which is 1-1 and then goes to conf record so NOLA is 5-5 and ARI is 4-6

RE: DDSPF is dumb, here's how I think the tiebreakers went down - infinitempg - 09-12-2020

(09-12-2020, 09:12 PM)JPach Wrote: infinite, for playoff seeding i think it takes ARI and NOLA H2H which is 1-1 and then goes to conf record so NOLA is 5-5 and ARI is 4-6

that's... what i said?

RE: DDSPF is dumb, here's how I think the tiebreakers went down - shadyshoelace - 09-13-2020

(09-12-2020, 11:08 PM)infinitempg Wrote:
(09-12-2020, 09:12 PM)JPach Wrote: infinite, for playoff seeding i think it takes ARI and NOLA H2H which is 1-1 and then goes to conf record so NOLA is 5-5 and ARI is 4-6

that's... what i said?

but have you considered the possibility that after looking at the records ARI and NOLA have against each other and finding that insufficient to break the tie, it then compares the record each team has against the teams in their conference?

RE: DDSPF is dumb, here's how I think the tiebreakers went down - Air Crou - 09-13-2020

Expand the playoffs to 4 teams. Problem solved.

RE: DDSPF is dumb, here's how I think the tiebreakers went down - JPach - 09-15-2020

(09-12-2020, 11:08 PM)infinitempg Wrote:
(09-12-2020, 09:12 PM)JPach Wrote: infinite, for playoff seeding i think it takes ARI and NOLA H2H which is 1-1 and then goes to conf record so NOLA is 5-5 and ARI is 4-6

that's... what i said?

have you ever not scrolled down in the code, I have lol