![[DEV] ISFL Forums](http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/images/emerald/logo.png "[DEV] ISFL Forums"){kind=logo}
+- [DEV] ISFL Forums (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums)
+-- Forum: Community (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Forum: Media (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=37)
+---- Forum: Graded Articles (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=38)
+---- Thread: *ISFL S25 Chicago vs. Austin Roster Comparison (/showthread.php?tid=26585)
*ISFL S25 Chicago vs. Austin Roster Comparison - platanocat - 10-04-2020
The beginning of the ISFL season starts tomorrow with Week 1!! As of right now, we can only speculate how well these teams with the data currently available to us. With the finalizing of their rosters, I decided to breakdown each team by the amount of TPE at each position. For this analysis, the 22 player active rosters for each team that was available in the TPE Tracker was used.
Quarterback
Advantage: Chicago +65 TPE
Players:
1. George O’Donnell: 892 TPE
2. Easton Cole: 827 TPE
Takeaway:
A close match up between the quarterbacks. George O’Donnell has the advantage for Chicago despite being 5 seasons younger.
Running Back
Advantage: Chicago +461 TPE
Players:
1. Baby Yoda: 926 TPE
2. Julio Tirtawidjaja: 636 TPE
3. Zoe Watts: 556 TPE
4. Kichwa Jones: 545 TPE
Takeaway:
Even at roster depth, Chicago pulls ahead by simply have the older players on average.
Wide Receiver
Advantage: Chicago +960 TPE
Players:
1. Sean O’Leary: 1205 TPE
2. Bender B. Rodriguez: 1093 TPE
3. Eddie Jeeta: 861 TPE
4. Net Gaines: 737 TPE
5. Videl-San: 689 TPE
6. Luca Scabbia: 647 TPE
7. Friedrich Vequain: 504 TPE
8. Griff Oberwald: 441 TPE
9. Raheem Okusi: 365 TPE
Takeaway:
When looking at the roster depth at wide receiver, it becomes apparent that these two teams are trying to focus their offense around supporting the passing game. Both teams have some pretty dedicated players, but with Chicago’s top two receivers at 1205 and 1093, their one man roster depth advantage almost becomes a moot point.
Tight End
Advantage: Chicago +1061
Players:
1. Tree Gelbman: 712 TPE
2. Von Hayes: 681 TPE
3. Peter Larson: 332 TPE
Takeaway:
While Austin has the older player, Chicago has definitely invested more in their tight ends.
Offensive Line
Advantage: Chicago +1034 TPE
Players:
1. Benson Bayley Jr: 752 TPE
2. Icebox Riposte: 406 TPE
3. Perry Tucker Jr: 322 TPE
4. Hal Fassingit: 235 TPE
5. Samuel Bakhtiari: 211 TPE
Takeaway:
Once again, Austin has the older players while Chicago was able to come up with higher earners.
Defensive End
Advantage: Austin +1683 TPE
Players:
1. Carolinabbq Isbest: 886 TPE
2. Troen Egghands: 861 TPE
3. Slinky Claxton: 699 TPE
4. Arik Eller: 389 TPE
5. Simeon Works: 374 TPE
Takeaway:
Coming up short in every position of this roster comparison so far, Austin was finally able to find something that they excel at. They have the roster depth, the older vets, and the highest earners. Chicago is not even close. I’m not so sure having all your advantage in one roster need is a game winning move, but hey I’m not a general manager.
Defensive Tackle
Advantage: Chicago +794 TPE
Players:
1. John “Tripod” Smirh: 844 TPE
2. Tyler Montain: 751 TPE
3. Daymond Brooks: 701 TPE
Takeaway:
Austin has a badass player in Tyler Montain, but he comes up short amid two hard hitting ships on the Chicago roster.
Linebacker
Advantage: Austin +653 TPE
Players:
1. Mike Hockhertz: 750 TPE
2. Mack Arianlacher: 720 TPE
3. Griffin Porter: 608 TPE
4. Honda Edmond: 597 TPE
5. Juan Domine: 522 TPE
Takeaway:
Hell yeah, another position Austin has the advantage in. They have the roster depth as well as the overall older players on average.
Cornerback
Advantage: Chicago +62 TPE
Players:
1. Osiris Firestorm-Fjord: 906 TPE
2. Dermot Lavelle Jr: 835 TPE
3. Colt Mendoza: 807 TPE
4. Tyler Oles Jr: 776 TPE
5. Tyron Shields: 681 TPE
6. Lesean Paris Crooks: 659 TPE
Takeaway:
Almost an even spread at the cornerback position. All the players in this list appear to be high earners, but Chicago was able eek by with an advantage.
Safety
Advantage: Chicago +4 TPE
Players:
1. Hamish MacAndrew: 745 TPE
2. Gregor Macgregor: 589 TPE
3. Maverick Bowie: 531 TPE
4. Raphael d’Alcott: 379 TPE
Takeaway:
D’Alcott, don’t know that he’s insane? Don’t you wanna move up in Chicago roster tonight? Move up in the roster toniiiight.
Kicker/Punter
Advantage: Chicago +309 TPE
Players:
1. Sam Sidekick: 615 TPE
2. Pseudo QB: 306 TPE
Takeaway:
Sam Sidekick the main super hero in this matchup. Both kickers are from S22, but Sam comes in at double the TPE.
Overall, you can total each team’s points in two ways. You can simply add the total amount of TPE each roster has accumulated as shown:
Chicago Total: 16,760 TPE
Austin Total: 14,346 TPE
Or you can total up the amount of advantage points each team has:
Advantage Points:
Chicago: +4750 TPE
Austin: +2336 TPE
I’m not sure when exactly these teams play each other on the schedule, but if they played week 1; Chicago has a +2414 TPE advantage over Austin. It’s clear that Austin’s main focus seems to be on defense, but they have a lot of older players that don’t appear to be very active in obtaining TPE. Chicago came out ahead in all but two positions.
If you have a request for a roster comparison, please DM on discord @platanocat on the ISFL Server or the London Royals Server.
Word Count: 841
RE: ISFL S25 Chicago vs. Austin Roster Comparison - LimJahey - 10-04-2020
This series you're doing is awesome! Also Von Hayes is a DE nowadays