[DEV] ISFL Forums
*Sarah's S30 Big Board - Printable Version

+- [DEV] ISFL Forums (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums)
+-- Forum: Community (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Forum: Media (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=37)
+---- Forum: Graded Articles (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=38)
+---- Thread: *Sarah's S30 Big Board (/showthread.php?tid=33355)

*Sarah's S30 Big Board - TakaMori152 - 07-05-2021

While I was making my Mock Draft, I wanted to try to do some sort of research on my own to make my own decisions on who would be picked where. Unfortunately, I don’t really have a good understanding of what each team’s needs are, so I ended up just going with the average choice for each pick. I think that most people are doing that, which makes it even more confusing, but I still wanted to do some sort of research about the draft. So, I decided to make an official Big Board.
In order to put this together, I took the official prospects list from the Mock Draft Point Task, then went to the TPE Tracker to get their position and TPE total. But I knew that that wouldn’t be enough. I’d need to see how well each player did throughout the season. I also learned from other people’s mock drafts and rankings that I should pay attention to each user’s activity.
For the player’s actual ability on the field, I was a bit unscientific and decided to simply rate them based on how their performance looked compared to others in their position. I always get weird looks when I rate on a scale of 1-10 because I don’t usually use the whole spectrum. I think of it like a percentage grade that you’d get in school, so a 6 is a D and an 8 is a B. Any player that didn’t even make an appearance still got a 5, but that 5 is a failing grade. As stated, this isn’t a very scientific grading system and based on my own opinion, but it should work as a good indicator of what tier each player is on.
As for user activity, I decided to use Total Posts as the best measurement of how involved the user is in the ISFL. This created a lot of disparity between players and allowed me to better stratify each level. It also helped separate certain players who were too close to each other in TPE and Rating.
I considered sending everything through a normal distribution to help solidify what percentile each player is in, but I thought that the Season Rating would be too vague to make that work and also it would take too much time to put together. So, in the final sequencing of players I just had to go through it unscientifically once again to make decisions based on my own bias of what level of TPE, Rating, and Posts qualify as enough to move someone up or down.
As this is a Big Board, it does not take into account the needs of the teams who hold each spot. It is based entirely on who the Best Player Available is at any given point, independent of position, and I’ve separated it by rounds so that it is easier for fellow prospects to see what tier they are in going into the draft on Thursday.

Ranking - Name - Position - TPE - Season Rating - Total Posts

Round One
  1. Vincent Sharpei Jr. - WR - 254 - 10 - 1880
  2. Sheriff Woody - LB - 258 - 9 - 1507
  3. Jason Garciaparra - CB - 256 - 7 - 1263
  4. Konstantin Selich - DT - 259 - 5 - 1106
  5. Dustin Parmelee - QB - 257 - 8 - 105
  6. Miles Weperom - S - 273 - 6 - 109
  7. Nick L. Back - TE - 250 - 9 - 1061
  8. Ricky Stanzi - QB - 250 - 8 - 654
  9. Jason Waterfalls - WR - 259 - 9 - 80
  10. Squidward Tentacles - WR - 249 - 9 - 1978
  11. Mason Malone - WR - 253 - 10 - 191
  12. Kiara Tenoh - RB - 242 - 10 - 82(+1)
  13. The Laz - CB - 238 - 9 - 1178
  14. Calvin Hobbes - WR - 242 - 9 - 90
    Round Two
  15. Ioe Torrent - DE - 240 - 7 - 94
  16. Cliff Burton - WR - 228 - 8 - 73
  17. Dee Walt - TE - 212 - 8 -700
  18. Bernie Sanders - OL - 208 - 8 - 2239
  19. Pepelegs Johnson - OL - 209 - 9 - 464
  20. Dominos Pizzaman - DT - 218 - 7 - 90
  21. Bradley Welch - WR - 208 - 8 - 99
  22. Tron Carter - RB - 202 - 8 - 1793
  23. Andy Fantuz - WR - 207 - 8 - 950
  24. Fuzzy George - S - 207 - 6 - 1406
  25. dont draft - LB - 201 - 7 - 3209
  26. Owen Reed - CB - 193 - 7 - 570
  27. Sal Ami - TE - 200 - 7 - 69
  28. Rex Crenshaw - TE - 188 - 7 - 74
    Round Three
  29. Miracle Whip - RB - 174 - 9 - 56
  30. Stewart Hellraiser - DE - 179 - 6 - 54
  31. Rocco Blade - DE - 177 - 6 - 66
  32. LaCarpetron Dukemarriot - LB - 174 - 8 - 55
  33. Richard Mansher - S - 169 - 7 - 42
  34. Clifford Wilson - OL - 170 - 6 - 97
  35. Jax Baker - RB - 164 - 9 - 50
  36. Matthew Holford - RB - 152 - 7 - 270
  37. Madison Beer - OL - 146 - 9 - 431
  38. Hex Aqua-Key'Kiann - LB - 152 - 8 - 51
  39. Tay Swizzle - WR - 132 - 7 - 187
  40. Levy Tate - K - 141 - 7 - 41
  41. Savior Hawkins - CB - 129 - 9 - 32
  42. Travis Scott - TE - 131 - 6 - 31
    Round Four
  43. Jay Jay-Jaymison JJ Jr - K - 123 - 8 - 230
  44. Hercules Kamealoha - DT - 97 - 6 - 2358
  45. Jimmy Nardello - RB - 112 - 8 - 25
  46. Jeremy Crouse - RB - 117 - 7 - 33
  47. Kai Marshall - WR - 108 - 7 - 19
  48. CMC's Burner - RB - 113 - 6 - 28
  49. Caleb Watt - DE - 94 - 7 - 31
  50. Ripoff CheeseBrand - S - 102 - 5 - 27
  51. Bill La T. de Dauterive - LB - 89 - 7 - 23
  52. Steve Atwater Jr. - S - 88 - 7 - 14
  53. Brent Suzuki WR - 85 - 8 - 33
  54. JJ Slasher - WR - 92 - 6 - 13
  55. Dorfus Jimbo Jr Jr - K - 81 - 6 - 1108
  56. Senbyo Korin - LB - 83 - 6 - 776
    Round Five
  57. Electric Squirrel - RB - 79 - 7 - 540
  58. Sigo Hendricks - RB - 83 - 6 - 19
  59. Yondu Yorukan - S - 77 - 7 - 21
  60. Sal Shaw - QB - 79 - 5 - 13
  61. Yaji Robe - RB - 70 - 7 - 748
  62. Deffo not Leroy Leroy - WR - 70 - 7 - 9
  63. Blake Faux Jr. - LB - 50 - 6 - 400
  64. Joseph Charles Raymond - DT - 70 - 5 - 7
  65. Brian Taylor - OL - 67 - 6 - 5
  66. Ringo Starr - RB - 60 - 6 - 6
  67. DeAndre Henry - RB - 52 - 5 - 16
  68. Joey McCarty - K - 50 - 5 - 3


RE: Sarah's S30 Big Board - katarn22 - 07-05-2021

I love reading articles like these to see how well they predict the actual results of the draft. Great stuff!

RE: Sarah's S30 Big Board - C9Van - 07-05-2021

I'm not going 1st round but I appreciate you putting me there Smile

RE: Sarah's S30 Big Board - Net - 07-06-2021

(07-05-2021, 05:03 PM)C9Van Wrote: I'm not going 1st round but I appreciate you putting me there Smile

Yes you will! Amazing user and will be shutdown

RE: Sarah's S30 Big Board - C9Van - 07-06-2021

(07-06-2021, 01:24 PM)Netlandic Wrote:
(07-05-2021, 05:03 PM)C9Van Wrote: I'm not going 1st round but I appreciate you putting me there Smile

Yes you will! Amazing user and will be shutdown

I will literally bet my entire bank (or however much you'd like) that I do not go 1st round I am that confident. (Hell anything really vs anyone.)

But I do appreciate your kind words pal <3