![[DEV] ISFL Forums](http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/images/emerald/logo.png "[DEV] ISFL Forums"){kind=logo}
+- [DEV] ISFL Forums (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums)
+-- Forum: Announcements (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=495)
+--- Forum: Announcements (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=32)
+---- Forum: Head Office Announcements (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=230)
+----- Forum: Rule Summit Results (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=518)
+----- Thread: S31 Universal Rules Summit Results (/showthread.php?tid=35195)
S31 Universal Rules Summit Results - Swanty - 09-19-2021
Hi ISFLers!
For the S31 Universal Rules Summit, GMs, Head Office members and Department Heads were encouraged to submit proposed changes to the rulebook and league procedure. With 31 voting members (14 ISFL teams, 6 DSFL teams, 6 ISFL HO members, 3 DSFL HO members, 1 League Owner, and 1 Sim Head), 22 votes were needed for a proposal to pass (>70% of the voting pool). 2 DSFL teams and 1 Sim Head did not submit votes by the deadline.
1. Reinstate the Most Outstanding Player award. Reasoning: MOP was an award that used to be voted on by the entire ISFL community to designate who they thought was most outstanding that season. It was eventually defunct, but I believe we can successfully reinstate it with anonymous voting. It would also be a fun and engaging award for presentation on the draft stream, ideally discussing runners up etc. as well.
25 For, 6 Against. Rule passes
2. Update rule IV.E.6 from: Retiring players cannot position switch. to: After a player has retired, the user may not take any additional action on behalf of the retired player unless the retirement is retracted. This includes but is not limited to swapping positions or archetypes, claiming TPE that was awarded after the retirement, participating in new TPE opportunities, or signing a new contract.
24 For, 7 Against. Rule passes
3. Head Office members can choose to opt in to voting for awards. If they intend to do so they need to alert the events team prior to the streaming of the first ISFL playoff game.
23 For, 8 Against. Rule passes
4. Laser's Position Change Overhaul: https://forums.sim-football.com/showthread.php?tid=35195&pid=519309#pid519309
21 For, 10 Against. Rule does not pass
5. Users have an option to purchase a single use PT Pass for that week. The more passes the person uses, the more expensive they become. The cost would reset after every season and cannot be used for UW or Season/Game Predictions. The cost of each pass is below. The cost is compounding as you would need 39,000,000 to get a full PT Pass.1st Pass: 2,000,000 2nd Pass: 4,000,000 3rd Pass: 8,000,000 4th Pass: 10,000,000 5th Pass: 15,000,000
16 For, 15 Against. Rule does not pass
6. If you have won the MDM in the last 5 seasons, you cannot be nominated. Once the 5 seasons are up, you can be nominated for MDM again. This only applies to ISFL MDM (so if you win DSFL MDM you can still be nominated after your ISFL draft).
14 For, 17 Against. Rule does not pass
7. Regarding the Most Dedicated Member award: each user may only win this award twice. These two awards may not come within 5 seasons of each other. For example, if a user wins MDM in S31 they cannot win again until S36. If a user does win two MDM awards, they are no longer eligible to be nominated for the award, however they will be inducted into the User Hall of Fame at the HoF induction closest following the awarding of their second MDM
8 For, 23 Against. Rule does not pass
8. Merge AC and WT into one task.
8 For, 23 Against. Rule does not pass
1, 2 and 3 will be implemented at the start of the S32 Offseason
RE: S31 Universal Rules Summit Results - Pat - 09-19-2021
Okay how did the position change proposal not pass? Our current system is awful and needs a facelift. If any of you ten that voted it down could explain why, I'd love to hear it.
RE: S31 Universal Rules Summit Results - JPach - 09-19-2021
(09-19-2021, 04:03 PM)Pat Wrote: Okay how did the position change proposal not pass? Our current system is awful and needs a facelift. If any of you ten that voted it down could explain why, I'd love to hear it.
Damn, that's funny
RE: S31 Universal Rules Summit Results - Sylphreni - 09-19-2021
Don't let this distract you from Zach Wilson's big day against New England.
RE: S31 Universal Rules Summit Results - infinitempg - 09-19-2021
So we passed MOP but not MDM reform? Cmon y’all I though the MDM reform was extremely popular in leadership discussion. MOP ended up being a disaster and was cut for good reason. Personally I don’t think it’s worthy of even being in the awards stream.
RE: S31 Universal Rules Summit Results - Ephenssta - 09-19-2021
(09-19-2021, 04:30 PM)infinitempg Wrote: So we passed MOP but not MDM reform? Cmon y’all I though the MDM reform was extremely popular in leadership discussion. MOP ended up being a disaster and was cut for good reason. Personally I don’t think it’s worthy of even being in the awards stream.
Isn't MOP the one that just went to MVP or OPOTY every single season? Might as well just have another QBOTY award at that point
RE: S31 Universal Rules Summit Results - IsaStarcrossed - 09-19-2021
So let me get this right, HO fought tooth and nail so they didn't have to vote for awards and we gave them what they wanted. Now we've voted to allow them to opt into voting whenever they want instead of just forcing them to all vote again?
So now a member of HO could see their player or a player on their team do well and opt into voting just to help swing the vote in their favor whenever they want?
And we as a league thought this was a good idea?
I don't often comment on rules, but this one is a pretty clear head scratcher that is wide open for abuse.
RE: S31 Universal Rules Summit Results - SwankyPants31 - 09-19-2021
Link to the position change suggestion goes somewhere most of us don't seem to have permission to view FYI
RE: S31 Universal Rules Summit Results - wuma - 09-19-2021
(09-19-2021, 04:32 PM)SwankyPants31 Wrote: Link to the position change suggestion goes somewhere most of us don't seem to have permission to view FYI
The real crime here.
RE: S31 Universal Rules Summit Results - Ephenssta - 09-19-2021
In other news, I dind't think rules were supposed to be implemented immediately when we're already four weeks into a season unless they were emergency rules proposals.