![[DEV] ISFL Forums](http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/images/emerald/logo.png "[DEV] ISFL Forums"){kind=logo}
+- [DEV] ISFL Forums (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums)
+-- Forum: Community (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=5)
+--- Forum: Media (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=37)
+---- Forum: Graded Articles (http://dev.sim-football.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?fid=38)
+---- Thread: *Season 7 Draft Review - One Season Later (/showthread.php?tid=8718)
*Season 7 Draft Review - One Season Later - majesiu - 05-19-2018
Recently there are some great articles about first draft classes, but since I'm part of the latest class (at least until Wednesday - just a little heads up/ self-promotion I have an article about newest draft class in the works too, so brace for it!). No graphs though since we use articles system that promotes pumping out words instead of high-quality content.
Few words about gradings/stats I used other than standard bloopers about players and their agents.
TPE is estimated and based on update pages, so there might be inconsistencies.
Grades are very subjective and the hugely affected by draft position - you won't get 10/10 for drafting obvious candidate. They are of course grades for GMs that decided to draft that player, not grades for individual players. I've been rather aggressive and critical since already some time passed to properly evaluate made choices.
Trade value: yet again my subjective scale - 10/10 - franchise player that can lead and manage the team, 7/8 - great player, 5 - solid piece, 3 - some upside, 1 - need pick another player to even make trade plausible.
Current trajectory uses a simplified scale of HoF/All-Star/NSFL Regular/DSFL Journeyman and is more of measure of what player probably accomplishes with current temp of growth, of course he can't defy these expectations if he starts earning with much better pace - even DSFL Journeyman candidates still can end up in Hall of Fame as it's very early in their careers.
Redraft potion is my personal order of player I'd probably draft if it was happening today with the current knowledge.
Let's get it going!
ROUND 1
#1
Howard Miller - WR - BenlongshawConsensus Top 1 Pick didn't disappoint, being top earner yet again (on top of having a great advantage of double dipping equipment from S6) and still would be the surefire pick to be taken #1 overall. Howard Miller had an as good rookie season as you can have with Yetis - 14 games, 590 yards, 13.1 average on 45 catches with 1 TD. The only thing that's surprising me is that BenLongshaw, despite being very active and having often great ideas is yet to pick up some league job or GM/coGM role.
TPE on draft night: 305
TPE now: 430
TPE Gained: 125
Grade on draft day: 8/10
Grade now: 9/10
Trade value: 9/10
Redraft position: #1
Current trajectory: Hall of Fame
#2
(via 
) Verso L'Alto - TE - nunccoepiVerso L'Alto had a great rookie season with 8 catching TD on 92 attempts for a total of 729 yards. Hawks definitely made a good move to trade up in order to get him. nunccoepi is superbly active and is often calming presence when hot topics are discussed. On top of that, he led Tijuana Luchadores to first Ultimini appearance in franchise history. A complete package as you could've asked in that draft.
TPE on draft night: 208
TPE now: 337
TPE Gained: 129
Grade on draft day: 7/10
Grade now: 10/10
Trade value: 9/10
Redraft position: #2
Current trajectory: Hall of Fame
#3
(via via ) Vladimir Fyodorovich - CB - majesiuFrom waiver pickup to 3rd overall pick to getting dumped (and somehow ending up Otter's traitor as part of the deal) in favour of new coGM is basically a quick recap of the story for Siberian Swatter so far. He had a decent rookie season in NSFL playing out of position at safety with 49 tackles and 7 sacks, but his playoff performance was disappointing and one of the factors why Otters didn't 4-peat. I like writing about users to give better overview, but it's weird when it's about myself - so let me say that I didn't have as much time last season as in my DSFL days, but that trade definitely added fuel to the fire!
TPE on draft night: 210
TPE now: 342
TPE Gained: 132
Grade on draft day: ?/10
Grade now: ?/10
Trade value: Salary filler in the trade with 1st rounder attached, solid 2/10
Redraft position: #4
Current trajectory: All-star (We all know CBs don't end up in Hall of Fame)
#4
(via 
) Mark Grau - WR - keanex Mark Grau was tearing it up in the DSFL representing Portland Pythons - 1213 total yards with 16.2 average and 6 TD. He should he get all possible awards for these monumental numbers. keanex is a member of awards community and have a bright career ahead of him. Without a doubt one the contenders for RoTY awards in season 8.
TPE on draft night: 184
TPE now: 282
TPE Gained: 98
Grade on draft day: 7/10
Grade now: 8/10
Trade value: 5/10
Redraft position: #5
Current trajectory: All-Star
#5
(via 
) Ryan Lefevre - LB - feve10My S6 DSFL Co-DPOY Ryan Lefevre had decent rookie season as the linebacker in Colorodo: 41 tackles, 4 sacks, 1 Interception are great numbers. We haven't seen feve10 recently, but that's just probably deserved offseason rest.
TPE on draft night: 90
TPE now: 90
TPE Gained: 0
Grade on draft day: 1/10
Grade now: 1/10
Trade value: 2/10
Redraft position: #13
Current trajectory: DSFL Journeyman
#6
(via 
) Desta Danger - CB - destadanger80 Tackles and 1 Sack mark numbers Desta Danger numbers in his rookie NSFL season for Yetis. He has potential and made strides in improving his abilities. Similarly to feve10 destadanger took some time off recently, but at least you can check out his dangerous articles.
TPE on draft night: 141
TPE now: 183
TPE Gained: 42
Grade on draft day: 6/10
Grade now: 5/10
Trade value: 4/10
Redraft position: #7
Current trajectory: NSFL Regular
#7
Ryan Applehort - QB - DaybeRyan Applehort had a hard time in the rookie season in NSFL with just 4/21 TD to INT ratio and 47.6 passing rating, but the hardest is done and he should only climb in quarterbacks hierarchy from now on. Daybe is active and one of the best earners in this class, in addiction led by him Portland Pythons won Ultimini.
TPE on draft night: 233
TPE now: 381
TPE Gained: 148
Grade on draft day: 9/10
Grade now: 10/10
Trade value: 9/10
Redraft position: #3
Current trajectory: All-star
#8
Mason Brown - LB - Fire-bredYet another instrumental Python player in their title run was Mason Brown with 104 tackles, 11 sacks, 2 interceptions and a tackle for loss. Fire-bred is very active with his articles and has massive bank account thanks to this.
TPE on draft night: 142
TPE now: 249
TPE Gained: 107
Grade on draft day: 7/10
Grade now: 7/10
Trade value: 6/10
Redraft position: #6
Current trajectory: All-star
ROUND 2
#9
Mike Miles - CB - AwkwardcowboyMike Miles played last season in DSFL with Coyotes having 65 tackles and 3 Interceptions. He'd probably have a chance to get called up if he didn't play for Liberty, but we should expect one more send down stint for him. AwkwardCowboy is a regular visitor on the site.
TPE on draft night: 111
TPE now: 141
TPE Gained: 30
Grade on draft day: 5/10
Grade now: 5/10
Trade value: 3/10
Redraft position: #12
Current trajectory: NSFL Regular
#10
(via ) Football Catcherman - WR - cpetrellaFootball Catcherman was a steady presence for San Antonio Marshalls good for 683 yards and 5 TDs throughout the season. cpetrella didn't have much time post draft and haven't improved in over a month. He is playing a stacked position, so the question remains if he ever gets called up.
TPE on draft night: 113
TPE now: 137
TPE Gained: 24
Grade on draft day: 5/10
Grade now: 2/10
Trade value: 2/10
Redraft position: #14
Current trajectory: DSFL Journeyman
#11
(via ) Cole McCoy - QB - TrueTexicanCole McCoy was second best QB in DSFL season with 72 rating and 14/15 passing rating. While very active pre and post-draft TrueTexican wasn't around for recently. Otters seem to agree that Cole McCoy might not be their QB of the future, as their GM already recreated as one.
TPE on draft night: 173
TPE now: 246
TPE Gained: 73
Grade on draft day: 8/10
Grade now: 5/10
Trade value: 4/10
Redraft position: #10
Current trajectory: NSFL Regular
#12
(via via ) Stone Hans - WR - Official DT Stone Hans was one the better receivers in DSFL for Kansas City with 755 total yards and 3 TD. Official DT is semi-active at best. Similar problems as with cptrella due to playing WR.
TPE on draft night: 90
TPE now: 114
TPE Gained: 24
Grade on draft day: 3/10
Grade now: 3/10
Trade value: 2/10
Redraft position: #15
Current trajectory: DSFL Journeyman
#13
(via ) Alvin Chipmunk - TE - andybjAlvin Chipmunk played yet another season with Marshalls, but not a very succesful one, just 320 yards without any TD. andybj is semi-active and you can count on his steady, albeit slow growth.
TPE on draft night: 140
TPE now: 178
TPE Gained: 38
Grade on draft day: 5/10
Grade now: 5/10
Trade value: 3/10
Redraft position: #9Current trajectory: NSFL Regular
#14
Thomas Kane III - LB - greygoosevodkaThomas Kane III had a decent season with 59 tackles and 7 sacks plus an interception. greygoosevodka has been inactive for over a month.
TPE on draft night: 91
TPE now: 91
TPE Gained: 0
Grade on draft day: 4/10
Grade now: 2/10
Trade value: 1/10
Redraft position: #17
Current trajectory: DSFL Journeyman
#15
(via ) Zach Skinner - DE - Titan127Zach Skinner is a steal for Liberty at 15th. Yet another cog in Ultimini team he had 31 tackles including league 3rd best 12th tackle for loss and 4 sacks. Titan127 is active and even making DSFL championship banners.
TPE on draft night: 98
TPE now: 173
TPE Gained:
Grade on draft day: 5/10
Grade now: 10/10
Trade value: 6/10
Redraft position: #9
Current trajectory: All-star
#16
Danny Vranos - CB - dannyxv17Danny Vranos was part of Tijuana team with 70 tackles and 4 sacks. dannyxv17 went inactive even before draft commenced.
TPE on draft night: 77
TPE now: 77
TPE Gained: 0
Grade on draft day: 2/10
Grade now: 1/10
Trade value: 1/10
Redraft position: #19
Current trajectory: DSFL Journeyman
ROUND 3
#17
Bubba Beau-Boucher - Safety - Angels_OtaniBubba Beau-Boucher had 59 tackles and 4 sacks with 14 PD while representing Coyotes last season. Angels_Otani wasn't around NSFL for two months now.
TPE on draft night: 108
TPE now: 108
TPE Gained: 0
Grade on draft day: 3/10
Grade now: 2/10
Trade value: 1/10
Redraft position: #22
Current trajectory: DSFL Journeyman
#18
(via via ) Joel Schroeder - CB - ShrodawgJoel Schroeder sat down whole seasons, as Portland team was really stacked. Shrodawg surprised with mid-season update giving some hope one day he might debut in NSFL.
TPE on draft night: 97
TPE now: 126
TPE Gained: 29
Grade on draft day: 3/10
Grade now: 4/10
Trade value: 3/10
Redraft position: #11
Current trajectory: NSFL Regular
#19
(via ) Dustin DeMarco - WR - Ramrod18Dustin DeMarco had a decent season with Portland - 443 total yards, 11.4 average and 1 TD. Ramrod18 saw his player drafted by Outlaws and haven't looked back like literally, we haven't seen him in our forums since then.
TPE on draft night: 64
TPE now: 64
TPE Gained: 0
Grade on draft day: 3/10
Grade now: 2/10
Trade value: 1/10
Redraft position: #18
Current trajectory: DSFL Journeyman
#20
Niraj Garrett - LB - BurdLinebacker for Kansas City Niraj Garrett had successful season with 69 tackles, 8 sacks and an interception. Burd isn't around since March.
TPE on draft night: 76
TPE now: 76
TPE Gained: 0
Grade on draft day: 3/10
Grade now: 2/10
Trade value: 1/10
Redraft position: #20
Current trajectory: DSFL Journeyman
#21
(via via ) DeAndre Green - WR - GridironGangGreen was a distant option for Coyotes, totalling only 107 yards with 1 TD. GridironGang isn't around since March too, even though he had an interesting start to his career with both article and press conference.
TPE on draft night: 82
TPE now: 82
TPE Gained:
Grade on draft day: 4/10
Grade now: 2/10
Trade value: 1/10
Redraft position: #21
Current trajectory: DSFL Journeyman
#22
(via ) Ugandan Knuckles - DE - bennyboy_456With Luchadores Ugandan Knuckles amassed 36 tackles and 5 sacks. bennyboy_456 went inactive in February.
TPE on draft night: 67
TPE now: 67
TPE Gained: 0
Grade on draft day: 3/10
Grade now: 2/10
Trade value: 1/10
Redraft position: #23
Current trajectory: DSFL Journeyman
#23
Sam Penner - QB - PensSam Penner lost his starting QB job to one of the top S8 prospects Brad Pennington, once touted as top prospect in his draft stock collapsed. Pens story is one of these that should've been much brighter ones and a lesson that sometimes it's better to discuss than trying to organize contests who have biggest eggplant (shoutout to @JKortesi81).
TPE on draft night: 134
TPE now: 134
TPE Gained: 0
Grade on draft day: 5/10
Grade now: 2/10
Trade value: 1/10
Redraft position: #16
Current trajectory: DSFL Journeyman
#24
(via ) Nash Teller - WR - NashNash Teller despite never improving his raw skills was successful this year with Pythons - just 188 yards but on 13.4 average with 1 TD. Only true one and done players in this draft(one as one post and done as never returned after this fact). Somewhat weird liberty picked him up here.
TPE on draft night: 50
TPE now: 50
TPE Gained: 0
Grade on draft day: 1/10
Grade now: 1/10
Trade value: 1/10
Redraft position: #26
Current trajectory: DSFL Journeyman
ROUND 4
#25
(via ) Jake Gore - WR - Super50Jake Gore got spot minutes with Marshals that were enough for 54 yards. As is the case with everyone at this point in the draft Super50 is inactive.
TPE on draft night: 67
TPE now: 67
TPE Gained: 0
Grade on draft day: 4/10
Grade now: 2/10
Trade value: 1/10
Redraft position: #24
Current trajectory: DSFL Journeyman
#26
PASS#27
Lucas Hendricks - WR - Tlindstrom15The last pick in season 7 draft Lucas Hendricks was also worst wide receiver last season - only 4 yards on 1 attempt for Tijuana. Today marks 2 months since Tlindstrom15 went inactive.
TPE on draft night: 62
TPE now: 62
TPE Gained: 0
Grade on draft day: ?/10 not much of choice
Grade now: 2/10
Trade value: 1/10
Redraft position: #25
Current trajectory: DSFL Journeyman
Thank you for reading, hope it gave a nice outlook of S7 draft class and you enjoyed it, the grades were subjective but current trajectory suggests that in this draft we had the potential for:
- 2 Hall of Famers
- 5 All-Stars
- 7 Regular NSFL Players
- 12 DSFL Journeyman
Added thoughts:
So almost 50/50 split between players making an impact in the big leagues and ones destined for DSFL teams, until they are forever forgotten. What's actually comforting is that there are highly influential players, that didn't recreate, so the league has an influx of contributing members, which is very important since burnout is so common.
While now we saw some players already in NSFL, they time to shine and dominate the league for a while may come during S10-12 when most of Season 1 and 2 players will retire or recreate (hopefully) and the league may be shallow on top-tier talent for a while just when Season 7 class enters their prime. Actually, you could almost create a team on their own, because positional variety was big, not top 6 players (in redraft rankings) play the same position. We will soon have RoTY awards revealed, but I think at some point in the future among players in this draft class Howard Miller might be the one that finally wins the Most Outstanding Player award while not being the quarterback. Defensive awards will also have many contenders, but I'd love to prove a point and win one for the sake and pride of all cornerbacks around the world. There is some hope for sleepers here too, as was the case with several players that updated and improved from nowhere in the middle of the season.
*Season 7 Draft Review - One Season Later - ckroyal92 - 05-19-2018
Longshaw was my co with SJS way back when, but he got burnt out. He's taking a more relaxed approach to it this time, so I wouldn't expect him to take on another role like that, at least not anytime soon.
*Season 7 Draft Review - One Season Later - manicmav36 - 05-19-2018
(05-19-2018, 09:41 AM)majesiu Wrote:)No graphs though since we use articles system that promotes pumping out words instead of high-quality content.
To be fair, we do have a statistical analysis section, that although underutilized, does reward the authors pretty well.
Great work though!
*Season 7 Draft Review - One Season Later - dropbear - 05-19-2018
(05-20-2018, 02:17 AM)ckroyal92 Wrote:Longshaw was my co with SJS way back when, but he got burnt out. He's taking a more relaxed approach to it this time, so I wouldn't expect him to take on another role like that, at least not anytime soon.
This. I'm in a leadership role with the Yeti, but that's about my ceiling right now.
Also, great write-up man! Appreciate the grade
I was hoping to see an analysis of our draft class at some point and you delivered in a big way!
*Season 7 Draft Review - One Season Later - Toasty - 05-20-2018
(05-19-2018, 09:41 AM)majesiu Wrote:No graphs though since we use articles system that promotes pumping out words instead of high-quality content.
#8
Yet another instrumental Python player in their title run was Mason Brown with 104 tackles, 11 sacks, 2 interceptions and a tackle for loss. Fire-bred is very active with his articles and has massive bank account thanks to this.
TPE on draft night: 142
TPE now: 249
TPE Gained: 107
Grade on draft day: 7/10
Grade now: 7/10
Trade value: 6/10
Redraft position: #6
Current trajectory: All-star
One is that your way for asking for a better scale for High quality content. and two you graded me too high you must've forgot about my summer absence.
*Season 7 Draft Review - One Season Later - majesiu - 05-20-2018
(05-19-2018, 05:17 PM)ckroyal92 Wrote:Longshaw was my co with SJS way back when, but he got burnt out. He's taking a more relaxed approach to it this time, so I wouldn't expect him to take on another role like that, at least not anytime soon.
(05-20-2018, 02:55 AM)BenLongshaw Wrote:This. I'm in a leadership role with the Yeti, but that's about my ceiling right now.
Also, great write-up man! Appreciate the grade
Sure, I understand and even without an official title you are doing a great job for Yetis, being their franchise face recently.
(05-20-2018, 09:10 AM)Fire-Bred Wrote:One is that your way for asking for a better scale for High quality content. and two you graded me too high you must've forgot about my summer absence.
Worry not I remembered about that, but you are top 6 TPE earner and you still might be when you return from that absence, so if you go back then to your normal activity this grades seems only fair.
*Season 7 Draft Review - One Season Later - AdamS - 05-20-2018
"Salary filler in the trade with 1st rounder attached, solid 2/10"
Boy....if you ever speak ill of my teammate like that again I WILL SLAP YOUR HEAD TRIANGULAR.
*Season 7 Draft Review - One Season Later - JKortesi81 - 05-20-2018
????????????
*Season 7 Draft Review - One Season Later - Toasty - 05-20-2018
(05-20-2018, 05:39 AM)majesiu Wrote:Worry not I remembered about that, but you are top 6 TPE earner and you still might be when you return from that absence, so if you go back then to your normal activity this grades seems only fair.
It seems ad if this class was loaded with a shit ton of IAs then if I am still top 6 when I return