My "Appeal"

[Oles]

Where is this written?  This sounds like a rule, yet is not anywhere in the rule book.  No one contacted me and told me I wasn't allowed to make a mock or similar post, and I've been war room for 3 NSFL pre-drafts.

The Maddox pick I will disagree with your assessment of public.  I proved that I had the information and shared the information as a certainty days before the pick was made.

It falls into the blanket of War Room members must receive the average for mock draft. Yes it probably should be written somewhere but if you can't make a mock draft in the PT thread it wouldn't make much sense for you to be allowed to make one in media.

Having the info prior to the draft is fine, if you had made the media before it started this wouldn't be a question, but you did it after the draft had begun with info that was received in a private setting, as you would have never known Maddox was guaranteed at number 2 until Slm either told you or made his pick. You would not have had access to the info in a public setting regardless as you are not a member of the Hawks, or in their LR as far as I know. You may have obtained the info before the draft, but there are many factors that play into it, such as the Sabercats still having the possibility of taking Maddox, which was only known as not the case because the draft has happened. It also wouldn't be unreasonable for the Sabercats to have taken him (or a team to trade up and take him) even if we currently have 2 WRs who are top earners. Since the post happened after the draft had begun (and after Maddox was picked). I understand that you received the info before the draft, but posting after the draft and when we have evidence of you being in a war room and seeing the results of the first round, makes it hard to say this wasn't a leak in some form, and that it is deserving of a punishment.