4/5 -1m - About like your other sigs, the other graders felt that your text was probably the weaker part. Mainly the Baltimore hawks text. For me, I think two things need to be kept in mind. I think you could lose the hawks logo or make it a lower opacity and larger in the background. Second, I think you should have had all the yellows a similar shade. I know it seems like a minor nitpick, and it is, but I think the thing for people to keep in mind is that when you forego certain elements, you have to make sure everything else is elevated. In this case, you don't have a traditional background. So your render editing becomes more important. Lastly, the render cut is a tad choppy. If you are using a quick-select tool, I would suggest either going over it with a history brush around the edges or manually selecting it.