Robot Mafia Game #1 GAME OVER TOWN WIN

7hawk77 · 05-16-2018, 10:23 AM

Scoring Rubric

Townie Scoring System:
-3 points for being lynched.
-2 points for each townie death they participated in (through a lynch or a vig-like ability).
-1 point for each townie mislynch they did not participate in, but were alive for.
-1 point for being endgamed (being alive at the end of the game and losing).
+1 point for each scum death they did not participate in, but were alive for.
+1 point for being NKed; +1 point bonus for being the first NK; +2 point bonus for being NKed as Vanilla.
+2 point for each scum role or ability investigated.
+2 points for each townie death prevented with an ability.
+2 points for each unsuccessful end-of-day vote against scum (including Mafia, SK, or CL).
+4 points for each scum death they participated in (through a lynch or vig-like ability).

Mafia scoring system:
-3 point for leaving the game without fulfilling win condition.
+1 point for each non-mafia death that occurs while alive.
+1 point for each Town power role killed by the Mafia kill while alive.
+1 point for each non-mafia lynch they participated in.
(Postgame) +3 points for Mafia victory
(Postgame) +1 point for each surviving member of their mafia team (cumulative with Mafia victory points)

Survivor scoring system:
-2 points for leaving the game without fulfilling win condition.
+1 point for each day or night period survived.

SK scoring system:
-1 point for leaving the game without fulfilling win condition.
+1 point for each night period they were alive for.
+2 points for each threat's death they participated in (this is anyone that can kill them or obtain information against them with an ability).

Cult Leader scoring system:
-1 point for leaving the game without fulfilling win condition.
-1 point for each dead recruit.
+2 points for each player successfully recruited.

Post game scoring:
+2 points for fulfilling any alternative/additional win conditions.
+3 points for each surviving member of their mafia team.
+4 points for townie win.
+4 points for non-SK neutral fulfilling win condition.
+8 points for SK win.

Penalties:
-12 points for forced replacing out/modkill for activit

adam2552 · 05-16-2018, 10:31 AM

slm played great..didn't fold when I threw the initial vote on him to get the game going. Which also led me to inspect him, and confirm my first alliance through the rest of the game. After that he really led the village, and with me in his pocket we could control the votes pretty easily.

7hawk77, I've never played with a Neopolitan before. What should be the goal? I played trying to ID villagers that I could the ally with.

Beaver · 05-16-2018, 10:33 AM

(05-16-2018, 11:09 AM)iamslm22 Wrote:Shouts to the Doc whoever that was. I'm wondering who the Robots tried to kill.

Night 1 was adam2552
Night 3 was you

Night 2 I thought you would've been a good kill since you took a leadership role but I was concerned about the doctor also thinking that and protecting you so I went with someone (SwagSloth) that voted Daybe and that I was pretty confident wouldn't be protected. Came back to you the next night hoping you were protected the night previous and therefore couldn't be again.

adam2552 · 05-16-2018, 10:36 AM

Nunc obviously did a great job as doc. 2 clutch saves, also never really put a target on himself from village or bots.

iamslm22 · 05-16-2018, 10:50 AM

Yea - makes a lot of sense why he was cautious voting and not being a leader. His job was to stay back and play it smart. We did great really.

iamslm22 · 05-16-2018, 10:51 AM

(05-16-2018, 10:33 AM)Beaver Wrote:Night 1 was adam2552
Night 3 was you

Night 2 I thought you would've been a good kill since you took a leadership role but I was concerned about the doctor also thinking that and protecting you so I went with someone (SwagSloth) that voted Daybe and that I was pretty confident wouldn't be protected. Came back to you the next night hoping you were protected the night previous and therefore couldn't be again.

Yea you did all you could - Daybe didn't play the strongest game.

7hawk77 · (This post was last modified: 05-16-2018, 11:35 AM by 7hawk77.)

Quick game summary:
Day 1 - No lynch, End of day Votes for Daybe -> SwagSloth, iamslm22, adam2552
Night 1 - nunccoepi/doc -> adam2552, Adam2552/neopolitan -> iamslm22, Beaver/Rolecop -> iamslm22, Daybe/NK -> adam2552
Day 2 - Lynched Daybe/Goon, 5 votes, iamslm22, Adam2552, Roly, Swagsloth, DeathOnReddit
Night 2 - Beaver/NK -> Swagsloth, adam/neo -> nunccoepi, nunccoepi/doc -> iamslm22
Day 3 - Lynched AdamS -> iamslm22, Beaver, nunccoepi, Roly
Night 3 - Beaver/NK -> iamslm22, nunccoepi/doc -> iamslm22, adam2552/neo -> roly
Day 4 - Lynched Beaver -> nunccoepi, iamslm22, adam2552, DeathOnReddit

@Roly - Human Vanilla
Lynched Daybe, +4
-2 points for each townie death they participated in (through a lynch or a vig-like ability).
+4 points for townie win.

@adam2552 - Human Neopolitan
unsuccessful end-of-day vote against scum +2
Lynched Daybe, +4
+4 points for each scum death they participated in (through a lynch or vig-like ability). (Beaver)
+4 points for townie win.
-1 point for each townie mislynch they did not participate in, but were alive for.

@DeathOnReddit - Human Vanilla
Lynched Daybe, +4
+4 points for each scum death they participated in (through a lynch or vig-like ability). (Beaver)
+4 points for townie win.
-1 point for each townie mislynch they did not participate in, but were alive for.

@iamslm22 - Human Vanilla
unsuccessful end-of-day vote against scum +2
Lynched Daybe, +4
-2 points for each townie death they participated in (through a lynch or a vig-like ability).
+4 points for each scum death they participated in (through a lynch or vig-like ability).
+4 points for townie win.

@nunccoepi - Human Doctor
+2 points for each townie death prevented with an ability. (adam2552)
Alive for daybe lynch +1
-2 points for each townie death they participated in (through a lynch or a vig-like ability).
+2 points for each townie death prevented with an ability. (iamslm22)
+4 points for each scum death they participated in (through a lynch or vig-like ability).
+4 points for townie win.

Dead:
@Daybe - Robot Goon
-3 point for leaving the game without fulfilling win condition.

@SwagSloth - Human Vanilla
unsuccessful end-of-day vote against scum +2
Lynched Daybe, +4
+4 points for townie win.
+1 point for being NKed;
+1 point bonus for being the first NK;
+2 point bonus for being NKed as Vanilla.

@AdamS - Human Vanilla
Alive for daybe lynch +1
-3 points for being lynched.
+4 points for townie win.

@Beaver - Robot Rolecop
+1 point for each non-mafia death that occurs while alive.
+1 point for each non-mafia lynch they participated in.
-3 point for leaving the game without fulfilling win condition.

Final rankings:

SwagSloth - 14 points
Adam2552 - 13 points
iamslm22 - 12 points
nunccoepi - 11 points
DeathOnReddit - 11 points
Roly- 6 points
AdamS - 2 points

Beaver - 0 points
Daybe - Negative 3 points

Obviously most people would view nunccoepi as the MVP as he saved two people which was back breaking, but it was a really good group effort. Swagsloth getting nightkilled as vanilla night one allowed adam2552 and nunccoepi to fully utilize their roles.

Again, Beaver played solid but was put in a really rough spot. Losing your partner on the first real lynch and bricking two night kills is pretty brutal.

If you think I scored something wrong based on the rubric, hit me up.

If this was a mafia league, we would basically have 5 more games, and you take your top 3 scores from those 6 games and whoever has the most point wins the league.

**nunccoepi** · 05-16-2018, 11:01 AM

Thanks that was a fun one. Hard not to pull suspicion to myself.. I might have gotten lucky with my choices but I enjoy the mental chess match that comes with the doctor role.

Also, Beaver in this version I was allowed to save people on consecutive nights, I just couldn't save myself. So I actually saved adam2552 night one and iamslm nights two and three. I would have tried to save adam2552 night 4 if needed.

7hawk77 · 05-16-2018, 11:06 AM

(05-16-2018, 09:31 AM)adam2552 Wrote:slm played great..didn't fold when I threw the initial vote on him to get the game going. Which also led me to inspect him, and confirm my first alliance through the rest of the game. After that he really led the village, and with me in his pocket we could control the votes pretty easily.

7hawk77, I've never played with a Neopolitan before. What should be the goal? I played trying to ID villagers that I could the ally with.

You played it great.

Basically you can only confirm vanilla villagers. When you inspected nunccoepi, I think you played it right. You learn if people are mafia or a power role but not which is which and you don't exactly want to out a power role. If you outed him then it wouldn't have accomplished anything.

Beaver · 05-16-2018, 11:10 AM

(05-16-2018, 12:01 PM)nunccoepi Wrote:Thanks that was a fun one. Hard not to pull suspicion to myself.. I might have gotten lucky with my choices but I enjoy the mental chess match that comes with the doctor role.

Also, Beaver in this version I was allowed to save people on consecutive nights, I just couldn't save myself. So I actually saved adam2552 night one and iamslm nights two and three. I would have tried to save adam2552 night 4 if needed.

Ah fuck you're right, I misread that.