2/5 for the first. 1/5 for the second.
I'm starting with the first two because they were touch-ups of previous sigs. I can't give them the credit they deserve because part of the work was already done on the previous sigs, so I can only grade the changes. The first, I really like the jersey work. White jerseys always look tight. I wish you could have done a little more, and the rest of it was nice change. The second, I wish you had re touched up the render cut-out and done more to the color change in general.
2/5 for the third. This one was on the edge of 3 for me but since we upped the payout, we are being a bit stricter. I like the helmet swap (it is well done) and the logo effect, but overall I would have liked to see more effects with the font, or the logo, the render, or general blending with the background and the render.
Keep up the good work!
I'm starting with the first two because they were touch-ups of previous sigs. I can't give them the credit they deserve because part of the work was already done on the previous sigs, so I can only grade the changes. The first, I really like the jersey work. White jerseys always look tight. I wish you could have done a little more, and the rest of it was nice change. The second, I wish you had re touched up the render cut-out and done more to the color change in general.
2/5 for the third. This one was on the edge of 3 for me but since we upped the payout, we are being a bit stricter. I like the helmet swap (it is well done) and the logo effect, but overall I would have liked to see more effects with the font, or the logo, the render, or general blending with the background and the render.
Keep up the good work!
![[Image: 58742_s.png]](https://signavatar.com/58742_s.png)
![[Image: 58742_v.png]](https://signavatar.com/58742_v.png)