(03-28-2020, 04:33 AM)Memento Mori Wrote:Active players have to play =/= snaps must be shared equally within position groups.
Thanks for the explanation, sorry if you’ve explained that before. My concern is you’ve not used judged it according to the depth charts, which can be found on the sim file, or the best base defense. Creating your own metric seems difficult and a good way of unnecessarily introducing human error into the process.
I agree it doesn't mean snaps are shared equally within position groups. You are correct in pointing out that this might be a flaw in how things ought to be calculated. As it stands right now I simply don't have the time to go and create custom weighting for each team. Maybe in a season or so once these rankings are more established and well known, teams will send me their depth charts/how they deploy players in order for me to get a more precise and accurate representation in the rankings. For now I use the same nickel defense weighting for every team
As it stands I merely use the TPE tracker and factor in recently used players. I played with the excel sheet and yes, when I just use the top 11, Myrtle Beach comes out with a score of 153 and Norfolk 142. When I factor in low TPE actives its Norfolk with 127 and Myrtle Beach with 125 (Tijuana is at 126 which is why MB is 5th and Norfolk is 3rd btw). Do you think the rankings would be represented more accurately if I just used the top 11?
Thanks for the discussion by the way this is the type of feedback/conversation I've wanted
