S22 DSFL Weeks 3 and 4 Resim

[ADwyer87]

So there's a no re-sim rule that's been applied in the past, and will be applied again in the future, but an exception is being made in this case?

What's different about this situation, the scale of errors was mentioned - how many players/teams were affected? If there were an error of this scale again in the future, would that also call for a re-sim again?

Does this rule need to be reviewed, or is the league ok with errors only affecting a single player/team being glossed over in the future with no consequence?

I am all for the re-sim and think this is absolutely the right decision to be made under these circumstances, I'm just a bit confused about the hard line on the rule otherwise and how this potential issue in could be resolved in the future

The "no re-sim policy" was set in place with these two decisions in S17 week 1:

http://nsfl.jcink.net/index.php?showtopic=15382
http://nsfl.jcink.net/index.php?showtopic=15402

Essentially we found significant errors with the Austin Copperheads and chose to re-sim week 1. After this, we found errors with many teams. We could have done a re-sim of the re-sim, but that's just not really good optics, when we had people screaming in the league that they were pissed about the re-sim originally. We also could have done a full season reset, which in hindsight was likely the best option, but given the super negative public backlash for us granting a re-sim in the first place and the NSFL GMs breathing down our necks, plus the fact that no matter what we decided, it was not ideal, HO basically took the stance of just trying to put this unfortunate situation behind us and put measures in place to help going forward.

I dont know any other errors that were in besides the Lackson error, but clearly that was something bigger than I think we ever expected to happen. Was just a small mistake, it happens, but clearly a huge impact in the sim. I think that would be the big difference. Generally speaking the rule is there to stop re-sim calls for things like "hey my speed was 75 when it should be 80"