S23 ISFL Awards

[Memento Mori]

But what do we do if someone from your team legitimately deserves the award? If YKW votes differently, I could have lost MVP to Cue (numbers wise I don't think I would have but it would have been close). I don't think a hard and fast rule is what we need in this case.

I don’t think a hard and fast rule is what we need either, apologies if my previous post was unclear.

I don’t think a team voting for its players is a problem, because every team gets one vote. If all or most teams vote for their own players, they are not at a significant advantage because every team can do that.

The problem is HO. Some HO members (which is why I brought up Bex’s ballot) are perfectly capable of voting for their teammates when they believe that they legitimately deserve the award, and not when they don’t. Hippo was not. HO is 2 NOLA players, a BAL player and a COL player. HO members have to be held to a different standard in awards voting because it’s not the case that every team has someone in HO.