Submission Date: 10/18
Submission Link: https://forums.sim-football.com/showthre...pid=376187
Contested Sig(s): All of them (1-7)
Mostly I just want to know what the changes were from 7/7 to 5 and 4/7? Like, I understand that it's templated and so all but the first will receive a reduced grade, but I thought I did a good job with my number and color swaps, as well as the background and general design.
Not sure what the standard is for a perfect score is in this league anymore but I think I could argue for at least a 6/7 for the actually graded one:
Definitely feel it used PS's tools effectively, the text blends with the general marble/gold theme, render is cut, and I think the swaps look good? I applied some filters from the filter gallery to give a more drawing-like feel as well. IDK maybe my eye for this isn't as good anymore.
The GFX team agreed that the submissions were deserving of a higher grade. We also agreed to bump up two more of the submissions, but keep the rest at 4/7, we are also opening up a discussion about asset re-use.
1. 5/7->6/7
2. 4/7->5/7
3. 4/7->5/7
4. Same grade
5. Same grade
6. Same grade
7. Same grade
$1,500,000
Submission Link: https://forums.sim-football.com/showthre...pid=376187
Contested Sig(s): All of them (1-7)
Mostly I just want to know what the changes were from 7/7 to 5 and 4/7? Like, I understand that it's templated and so all but the first will receive a reduced grade, but I thought I did a good job with my number and color swaps, as well as the background and general design.
Not sure what the standard is for a perfect score is in this league anymore but I think I could argue for at least a 6/7 for the actually graded one:
Quote:Graphics that receive this grade make effective use of photoshop's suite of tools. The text blends with the rest of the signature, the render is well cut, the jersey swap looks natural. There is just one issue holding this signature back from being a 7.
Definitely feel it used PS's tools effectively, the text blends with the general marble/gold theme, render is cut, and I think the swaps look good? I applied some filters from the filter gallery to give a more drawing-like feel as well. IDK maybe my eye for this isn't as good anymore.
The GFX team agreed that the submissions were deserving of a higher grade. We also agreed to bump up two more of the submissions, but keep the rest at 4/7, we are also opening up a discussion about asset re-use.
1. 5/7->6/7
2. 4/7->5/7
3. 4/7->5/7
4. Same grade
5. Same grade
6. Same grade
7. Same grade
$1,500,000
![[Image: 55457_s.gif]](https://signavatar.com/55457_s.gif)
