I started looking into this just to see if Sarasota had a chance of breaking the record. Through 9 games Sarasota has allowed 135 points, good for 15 ppg allowed.
Here are the top marks in league history
1. S3
Arizona Outlaws 166 Points Allowed 14 Games 11.86 PAPG
2. S2
Arizona Outlaws 175 Points Allowed 14 Games 12.5 PAPG
3. S1
Orange County Otters 196 Points Allowed 14 Games 14 PAPG
4. S9
New Orleans Secondline 197 Points Allowed 14 Games 14.07 PAPG
5. S4
Arizona Outlaws 203 Points Allowed 14 Games 14.5 PAPG
6. S1
Arizona Outlaws 204 Points Allowed 14 Games 14.57 PAPG
7. S22
Yellowknife Wraiths 196 Points Allowed 13 Games 15.08 PAPG
Sarasota has a chance to break the "modern" record set by Yellowknife, but I doubt anyone touches the S3 record.
Here are the top marks in league history
1. S3

2. S2

3. S1

4. S9

5. S4

6. S1

7. S22

Sarasota has a chance to break the "modern" record set by Yellowknife, but I doubt anyone touches the S3 record.