Major Announcements

[ADwyer87]

What I said initially was that you can't accurately compare someone's work at one position to someone else's work at another position. For instance, if I played RB for 3 seasons and QB for the following 4 seasons, and I played at an above average level as a RB, there's no meaningful way to compare how I performed among other RBs, to the performance of QBs for the first 3 seasons, therefore post-position swap data is the only relevant data.

I hope that's not as confusing as I think it is rereading it.

I think i kinda get it. I dont think we would be comparing between players at different positions though?

@ADwyer87 @iamslm22 if you're going to consider the whole body of work of a player who's switched, then I think the HOF shouldn't have position designations. People should just be in the HOF, not in for any one position.

I also think this opens the door to things like an all-decade (S1 - 10, S11 - 20 etc.) team that does assign by position.

I mean, we could always just put a /