*The Awards Committee Decides

[Modern_Duke]

Wait are these the real awards? If so I should be OROTY since I’m actually a rookie. Williams played on a team last year. He’s basically Ben Simmons but he actually participated in games.

No, only real if you want them to be.

That’s an interesting point that I didn’t consider. Not sure if there is an official ruling on that. To counter your point though, baseball doesn’t consider late season call ups. Aaron judge had like 100 plate appearances the year before he won rookie of the year.