01-12-2020, 08:42 PM (This post was last modified: 01-12-2020, 08:42 PM by Nokazoa.)
1 and 2: 4 (2 x 1m = 2m) Both pretty strong contenders, I felt, out of the two, Gordon was stronger. I think Lewis's render had the least done and the background doesnt do a lot. However it is very strong font wise. Whats holding Gordon back the most is your light effect (i.e the rays). Taking them off the face will do wonders for the sig. I will point out the lightening effect is nice, but I would have liked it the light coming off of it to hit the render.
3: 4.5/51.25m Honestly this is pretty perfect. I think you have a few issues holding it back. One is the glaring cut off on the shadows around the left arm. Typically happens when you do the effect near an edge. The name swap is nice. It does look apparent when you tak into account it doesn't follow the folds or shadows, and your helmet logo swap doesn't look to curve with the helmet which is noticeable since the helmet is a focal point in the sig. I think the "Warp Transform" tool can alleviate this in Gimp but I didn't take points off for that to be honest, nor did anyone else mention that. Also your lens flare placement is pretty on point.