*Too far or not far enough?

[kckolbe]

No dude read my post again, I said I agree with you that the outcome of Gibson's added TPE was more. I didn't say it was insignificant at all. All I was saying is that although it was impactful in the sim (though ER says it didn't effect our win totals when he re simmed the season a bunch), the intent was clearly not there. I specifically said "I don't see how you can argue Gibson is worse, though I can see the argument that it had more of an effect."

My point is that when the Gibson stuff came up, you said it had no significant affect. For Noble, you said it likely gave them a win.